Comparison of oscillator analysis tools: Difference between revisions

From LifeWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 15: Line 15:
-->
-->


== Oscillators ==<!--add: Caterer, CAViewer-->
== Oscillators ==
{| class="wikitable" style="margin-left: auto; margin-right: auto; text-align: center;"
{| class="wikitable" style="margin-left: auto; margin-right: auto; text-align: center;"
! colspan="2" | Datum
! colspan="2" | Datum
Line 24: Line 24:
! [[Nakano]]
! [[Nakano]]
! [[LifeViewer]]
! [[LifeViewer]]
! [[CAViewer]]
! [[Caterer (program)|Caterer]]
! [[Catagolue]]
! [[Catagolue]]
|-
|-
Line 33: Line 35:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''<!--confirm limit-->
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''<!--confirm limit-->
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''<ref group="n">no upper limit as of build 1285 (possibly earlier)</ref>
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''<ref group="n">no upper limit as of build 1285 (possibly earlier)</ref>
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
|-
|-
Line 43: Line 47:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 52: Line 58:
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 61: Line 69:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 71: Line 81:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
|-
|-
Line 80: Line 92:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
|-
|-
Line 89: Line 103:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 99: Line 115:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 108: Line 126:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 117: Line 137:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 127: Line 149:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 136: Line 160:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 146: Line 172:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 155: Line 183:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 164: Line 194:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 174: Line 206:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 183: Line 217:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 193: Line 229:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 202: Line 240:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 212: Line 252:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 221: Line 263:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 230: Line 274:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
|-
|-
Line 239: Line 285:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
|-
|-
Line 248: Line 296:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#888888; color:#a1b2c3" | '''?'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
|}
|}
Line 260: Line 310:
! [[Nakano]]
! [[Nakano]]
! [[LifeViewer]]
! [[LifeViewer]]
! [[CAViewer]]
! [[Caterer (program)|Caterer]]
! [[Catagolue]]
! [[Catagolue]]
|-
|-
Line 269: Line 321:
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 278: Line 332:
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
|-
|-
Line 285: Line 341:
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#c6efce; color:#006100" | '''Yes'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
Line 290: Line 348:
|-
|-
! [[Signature map]]
! [[Signature map]]
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
Line 299: Line 359:
|-
|-
! [[Domain coloring]]
! [[Domain coloring]]
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''
| style="background-color:#ffc7ce; color:#9c0006" | '''No'''

Revision as of 09:47, 24 September 2025

This page compares tools used for analyzing still lifes, oscillators and spaceships alongside the information they output.

We assume that the input pattern runs in B3/S23, as these tools are used for computing information for wiki infoboxes.

Oscillators

Datum Oscar Oscillizer Oscillizer-Web Oscilloscope Nakano LifeViewer CAViewer Caterer Catagolue
Period Yes ≤1200 ≤~1000 ≤50000 Yes Yes[n 1] ? ? Yes
Mod Value No No No No Yes Yes ? ? No
Transformation No No No No No Yes ? ? No
Kinetic symmetry No No No No Yes No ? ? No
Population Minimum No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes ? ? Yes
Maximum No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes ? ? Yes
Average No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes ? ? No
Active cells Rotor No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes ? ? No
Stator No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes ? ? No
Total No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes ? ? No
Volatility Standard No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes ? ? No
Strict No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes ? ? No
Heat Minimum No Yes No No Yes Yes ? ? No
Maximum No Yes No No Yes Yes ? ? No
Average No Yes No Yes Yes Yes ? ? No
Temperature Active No Yes No Yes Yes Yes ? ? No
Rotor No Yes No No Yes Yes ? ? No
Bounding box XY No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes ? ? No
Area No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes ? ? No
Supported
by rules
Minimum (outer-totalistic) No Yes No No Yes No ? ? No
Maximum (outer-totalistic) No Yes No No Yes No ? ? No
Minimum (isotropic) No No No No Yes No ? ? Yes
Maximum (isotropic) No No No No Yes No ? ? Yes
apgcode No No No No Yes No ? ? Yes

Mapping

Map type Oscar Oscillizer Oscillizer-Web Oscilloscope Nakano LifeViewer CAViewer Caterer Catagolue
Period map No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No No No
Frequency map No No No Yes No Yes No No No
Heat map No No No Yes No No No No No
Signature map No No No No No No No No No
Domain coloring No No No No No No No No No

Spaceships

Datum Oscar Nakano LifeViewer Catagolue
Period No Yes Yes Yes
Mod Value No Yes Yes No
Transformation No No Yes No
Kinetic symmetry No Yes No No
Population Minimum No Yes Yes Yes
Maximum No Yes Yes Yes
Average No Yes Yes No
Direction No No Yes No
Slope No No Yes No
Speed Unsimplified Yes Yes Yes No
Simplified No Yes Yes No
Heat Minimum No Yes Yes No
Maximum No Yes Yes No
Average No Yes Yes No
Bounding box XY No Yes Yes No
Area No Yes Yes No
Supported by rules Minimum (outer-totalistic) No Yes No No
Maximum (outer-totalistic) No Yes No No
Minimum (isotropic) No Yes No Yes
Maximum (isotropic) No Yes No Yes
apgcode No Yes No Yes

Example maps

The p96 Hans Leo hassler is used for these demos due to its low period and diverse set of subperiods. Legends are not included.

LifeViewer does not display the initial pattern inside the period map as to do so would be redundant given that the input pattern is already accessible.

Period maps


Frequency maps


Heat maps

Notes

  1. ↑ no upper limit as of build 1285 (possibly earlier)