Minecraft Flying Machine CA

[Schiaparelliorbust]

I've seen this mentioned before:

What about a rule that simulates minecraft's flying slime block machine technology?

but nothing has been done about it. Mumbo Jumbo's newest video reminded me of it. He made a pseudo-flying machine gun (it has limited resources so technically not a true gun) and the top comment is:

octet33
7 hours ago
Ahh, Minecraft: everyone's favorite cellular automaton.

In the thread where muzik wrote the suggestion, they said it would have to be 3d, but I doubt it. They already did request a 2d version. This would still be very hard to make. Some reasons why:

• You would have to keep track of which pistons is pushing/pulling which block.

• Pistons would be slow because you have to update blocks the piston is pushing gradually.

• Because of the last point, pistons might fire at wrong times

• There are some complicated redstone concepts you have to implement like tranparency and quasi-connectivity

• Slime/Honey blocks might slow things down even further

• If made, this would require an enormous number of cell states

Blocks to add:

• Slime blocks

• Honey blocks

• Pistons(both types)

• Redstone blocks

• Observers

• A solid (non-transparent) block

Maybe list:

• Obsidian (unmovable)

• Glazed terracotta(can't be pulled with slime/honey blocks)

• Transparent block

Feel fry to simplify it and tell me if I've made any mistakes please.

[Ian07]

Rule:UDirMCSlime? It's apparently still buggy, but it should be a good starting point.

[Schiaparelliorbust]

I can't copy the rule table into Golly. I get an error message saying bad basic vaules.

[Ian07]

I can't copy the rule table into Golly. I get an error message saying bad basic vaules.

You copied it from the source view, correct? Not the default view?

[Schiaparelliorbust]

I can't copy the rule table into Golly. I get an error message saying bad basic vaules.

You copied it from the source view, correct? Not the default view?

Thanks! Problem solved! I'll check out the rule and see what bugs it has.

Edit: I don't understand what some of the states are.

Code: Select all

0: vacc 1: slime block 2: piston 3: redstone block 4: piston extention 5: slime move 1 6: slime move 2 7: slime move 3 8: slime move 4 9: slime move 5 10: slime move 6 11: slime move 7 12: slime move 8 13: slime move 9 14: slime move 10 15: slime move 11 16: slime move 12 17: rsblock move 1 18: rsblock move 2 19: rsblock move 3 20: rsblock move 4 21: rsblock move 5 22: rsblock move 6 23: rsblock move 7 24: rsblock move 8 25: rsblock move 9 26: rsblock move 10 27: rsblock move 11 28: rsblock move 12 29: piston move 1 30: piston move 2 31: piston move 3 32: piston move 4 33: piston move 5 34: piston move 6 35: piston move 7 36: piston move 8 37: piston move 9 38: piston move 10 39: piston move 11 40: piston move 12 41: piston active

Why are there so many piston, rsblock, and slime move states? It can't be just the direction. I'm too lazy to look at the rule table.

[yujh]

I can't copy the rule table into Golly. I get an error message saying bad basic vaules.

You copied it from the source view, correct? Not the default view?

Thanks! Problem solved! I'll check out the rule and see what bugs it has.

Edit: I don't understand what some of the states are.

Code: Select all

0: vacc 1: slime block 2: piston 3: redstone block 4: piston extention 5: slime move 1 6: slime move 2 7: slime move 3 8: slime move 4 9: slime move 5 10: slime move 6 11: slime move 7 12: slime move 8 13: slime move 9 14: slime move 10 15: slime move 11 16: slime move 12 17: rsblock move 1 18: rsblock move 2 19: rsblock move 3 20: rsblock move 4 21: rsblock move 5 22: rsblock move 6 23: rsblock move 7 24: rsblock move 8 25: rsblock move 9 26: rsblock move 10 27: rsblock move 11 28: rsblock move 12 29: piston move 1 30: piston move 2 31: piston move 3 32: piston move 4 33: piston move 5 34: piston move 6 35: piston move 7 36: piston move 8 37: piston move 9 38: piston move 10 39: piston move 11 40: piston move 12 41: piston active

Why are there so many piston, rsblock, and slime move states? It can't be just the direction. I'm too lazy to look at the rule table.

You need to look at the rule table to understand it, but you can just try it here:

Code: Select all

x=1,y=5,rule=UDirMCSlime
A!

[Schiaparelliorbust]

You copied it from the source view, correct? Not the default view?

Thanks! Problem solved! I'll check out the rule and see what bugs it has.

Edit: I don't understand what some of the states are.

Code: Select all

0: vacc 1: slime block 2: piston 3: redstone block 4: piston extention 5: slime move 1 6: slime move 2 7: slime move 3 8: slime move 4 9: slime move 5 10: slime move 6 11: slime move 7 12: slime move 8 13: slime move 9 14: slime move 10 15: slime move 11 16: slime move 12 17: rsblock move 1 18: rsblock move 2 19: rsblock move 3 20: rsblock move 4 21: rsblock move 5 22: rsblock move 6 23: rsblock move 7 24: rsblock move 8 25: rsblock move 9 26: rsblock move 10 27: rsblock move 11 28: rsblock move 12 29: piston move 1 30: piston move 2 31: piston move 3 32: piston move 4 33: piston move 5 34: piston move 6 35: piston move 7 36: piston move 8 37: piston move 9 38: piston move 10 39: piston move 11 40: piston move 12 41: piston active

Why are there so many piston, rsblock, and slime move states? It can't be just the direction. I'm too lazy to look at the rule table.

You need to look at the rule table to understand it, but you can just try it here:

Code: Select all

x=1,y=5,rule=UDirMCSlime
A!

I can try it here? That pattern is just a slime block.

[yujh]

Thanks! Problem solved! I'll check out the rule and see what bugs it has.

Edit: I don't understand what some of the states are.

Code: Select all

0: vacc 1: slime block 2: piston 3: redstone block 4: piston extention 5: slime move 1 6: slime move 2 7: slime move 3 8: slime move 4 9: slime move 5 10: slime move 6 11: slime move 7 12: slime move 8 13: slime move 9 14: slime move 10 15: slime move 11 16: slime move 12 17: rsblock move 1 18: rsblock move 2 19: rsblock move 3 20: rsblock move 4 21: rsblock move 5 22: rsblock move 6 23: rsblock move 7 24: rsblock move 8 25: rsblock move 9 26: rsblock move 10 27: rsblock move 11 28: rsblock move 12 29: piston move 1 30: piston move 2 31: piston move 3 32: piston move 4 33: piston move 5 34: piston move 6 35: piston move 7 36: piston move 8 37: piston move 9 38: piston move 10 39: piston move 11 40: piston move 12 41: piston active

Why are there so many piston, rsblock, and slime move states? It can't be just the direction. I'm too lazy to look at the rule table.

You need to look at the rule table to understand it, but you can just try it here:

Code: Select all

x=1,y=5,rule=UDirMCSlime
A!

I can try it here? That pattern is just a slime block.

No, just for convenience, but I don’tk know why lv doesn’t accept the rule table.(I’m lazy too!)

I don’t understand anything of the rule:notice: I don’t have vpn )

[Schiaparelliorbust]

No, just for convenience, but I don’tk know why lv doesn’t accept the rule table.(I’m lazy too!)
I don’t understand anything of the rule:notice: I don’t have vpn )

What is lv?

[yujh]

No, just for convenience, but I don’tk know why lv doesn’t accept the rule table.(I’m lazy too!)
I don’t understand anything of the rule:notice: I don’t have vpn )

What is lv?

Life viewer

octet33
7 hours ago
Ahh, Minecraft: everyone's favorite cellular automaton.

definetely don’t agree!!!!!

[Schiaparelliorbust]

No, just for convenience, but I don’tk know why lv doesn’t accept the rule table.(I’m lazy too!)
I don’t understand anything of the rule:notice: I don’t have vpn )

What is lv?

Life viewer

octet33
7 hours ago
Ahh, Minecraft: everyone's favorite cellular automaton.

definetely don’t agree!!!!!

Okay then, it's kind of strange that it doesn't accept it. And Minecraft technically isn't a cellular automaton but in the video it is without any mobs and stuff I think, and it really is nice though certainly not everyone's favorite. It is supposed to be a game, not a CA.

[Saka]

Why are there so many piston, rsblock, and slime move states? It can't be just the direction. I'm too lazy to look at the rule table.

I believe this was my attempt at implementing the 12-block push limit. However, it doesn't work, because of splits:

Code: Select all

x = 7, y = 13, rule = uDirMCSlime
2.A3.A$.6A$4.A$4.A$.4A$.C2.A$B4A$4.3A$4.A.A$4.A.A$4.A.A$2.5A$2.A3.A!

I haven't bothered to fix it, and I lost the nutshell file as well, so I'd have to start from scratch if I wanted to really add anything.
Here's an example flying machine that works in MC (Java) as well.

Code: Select all

x = 8, y = 9, rule = uDirMCSlime
6.C$3.AB.A$3.A2.AC$3.A2.BA$3.A.3A$2.CA.A$B.A2.A.C$A4.B.A$8A!

A minecraft redstone CA shouldn't be too hard as well.

[Schiaparelliorbust]

Why are there so many piston, rsblock, and slime move states? It can't be just the direction. I'm too lazy to look at the rule table.

I believe this was my attempt at implementing the 12-block push limit. However, it doesn't work, because of splits:

Code: Select all

x = 7, y = 13, rule = uDirMCSlime
2.A3.A$.6A$4.A$4.A$.4A$.C2.A$B4A$4.3A$4.A.A$4.A.A$4.A.A$2.5A$2.A3.A!

I haven't bothered to fix it, and I lost the nutshell file as well, so I'd have to start from scratch if I wanted to really add anything.
Here's an example flying machine that works in MC (Java) as well.

Code: Select all

x = 8, y = 9, rule = uDirMCSlime
6.C$3.AB.A$3.A2.AC$3.A2.BA$3.A.3A$2.CA.A$B.A2.A.C$A4.B.A$8A!

A minecraft redstone CA shouldn't be too hard as well.

That is very cool. And I use that word sparingly. I kind of wish there were observers, but that's okay. How do pistons push exactly? I don't see any piston heads, only single blocks. A Minecraft redstone CA would be nice. I think it should be at least two-layered, because you often have to place redstone dust on top of blocks. It should also be bird's-eye view.

Edit: Are there sticky pistons or just regular ones? It looks like the machine you gave me uses only pushes and no pulls.

[bubblegum]

How do pistons push exactly? I don't see any piston heads, only single blocks.

It detects a last-phase push block (for a slime block, the blue-green with the least blue) and replaces it with a piston arm for a "pushing" effect.

[Saka]

How do pistons push exactly? I don't see any piston heads, only single blocks.

Edit: Are there sticky pistons or just regular ones? It looks like the machine you gave me uses only pushes and no pulls.

Piston head is state 4.

You can read the comments on the ruleTable for what each state is. There are only slime blocks, redstone blocks, and right-facing nonstick pistons.

[Schiaparelliorbust]

How do pistons push exactly? I don't see any piston heads, only single blocks.

Edit: Are there sticky pistons or just regular ones? It looks like the machine you gave me uses only pushes and no pulls.

Piston head is state 4.

You can read the comments on the ruleTable for what each state is. There are only slime blocks, redstone blocks, and right-facing nonstick pistons.

Fair enough. Though I do think that if we make a redstone CA it should have blocks facing all directions.

Edit: I think we should start trying to make it. It should have:
Redstone dust
Observers
Pistons (both types)
Redstone blocks
Repeaters
Comparators
Transparent and opaque blocks
Redstone torches

Other blocks I omitted (buttons, droppers etc.) because they wouldn't work in a CA.

[NoAyeBeardo]

What's the fastest possible speed?
I got to c/42:

Code: Select all

x = 8, y = 6, rule = uDirMCSlime
3.2AC$3.ABA$2.CA.A.C$pQDA2.B.A$A6.A$8A!

[Saka]

What's the fastest possible speed?
I got to c/42:

Code: Select all

x = 8, y = 6, rule = uDirMCSlime
3.2AC$3.ABA$2.CA.A.C$pQDA2.B.A$A6.A$8A!

In this CA (assuming you mean that, since the one above won't work in MC as the bottom segment is 13 blocks)? Here's a c/28o:

Code: Select all

x = 4, y = 4, rule = uDirMCSlime
.C$BA.C$AB.A$4A!

[Schiaparelliorbust]

I tried to make flying machines but I'm absolutely terrible at it. Can we get started on the redstone CA?

[Saka]

Here's another question: What's the smallest (by population, bb if populations are equal) flying machine that works both in the uDirMCSlime rule and actual minecraft?
Here's 30 cells in an 8x8 bounding box

Code: Select all

x = 8, y = 8, rule = uDirMCSlime
5.C$3.B.2AC$3.A2.BA$3.A.3A$2.CA.A$B.A2.A.C$A4.B.A$8A!

[Schiaparelliorbust]

Here's another question: What's the smallest (by population, bb if populations are equal) flying machine that works both in the uDirMCSlime rule and actual minecraft?
Here's 30 cells in an 8x8 bounding box

Code: Select all

x = 8, y = 8, rule = uDirMCSlime
5.C$3.B.2AC$3.A2.BA$3.A.3A$2.CA.A$B.A2.A.C$A4.B.A$8A!

It seems that this spaceship powers its pistons diagonally, though I don't see anything like that on the quasi-connectivity article on the Minecraft wiki. I'm not very good at this so I might be wrong, I can try it in Minecraft right now if you'd like.
Edit: Tried it out, works perfectly. Also, I'm playing Minecraft in Shakespearian, so when I tried to look up "piston" it didn't work. Turns out they're "extenders" and "gluey extruders".

[Moosey]

It seems that this spaceship powers its pistons diagonally, though I don't see anything like that on the quasi-connectivity article on the Minecraft wiki. I'm not very good at this so I might be wrong, I can try it in Minecraft right now if you'd like.

Last I checked, all of flying machine technology in MC is based on that kind of interaction, so it should definitely work

Bi-directional flying machine CA when (either 180 or 90 degrees apart)? Maybe with fewer states so that it can be rule-tabled

[Schiaparelliorbust]

It seems that this spaceship powers its pistons diagonally, though I don't see anything like that on the quasi-connectivity article on the Minecraft wiki. I'm not very good at this so I might be wrong, I can try it in Minecraft right now if you'd like.

Last I checked, all of flying machine technology in MC is based on that kind of interaction, so it should definitely work

Bi-directional flying machine CA when (either 180 or 90 degrees apart)? Maybe with fewer states so that it can be rule-tabled

Yes, perhaps before we start the redstone CA we can make add other directional pistons or sticky ones.

[Moosey]

It seems that this spaceship powers its pistons diagonally, though I don't see anything like that on the quasi-connectivity article on the Minecraft wiki. I'm not very good at this so I might be wrong, I can try it in Minecraft right now if you'd like.

Last I checked, all of flying machine technology in MC is based on that kind of interaction, so it should definitely work

Bi-directional flying machine CA when (either 180 or 90 degrees apart)? Maybe with fewer states so that it can be rule-tabled

Yes, perhaps before we start the redstone CA we can make add other directional pistons or sticky ones.

Maybe. adding Sticky Pistons to udirmcslime should also be possible

[Schiaparelliorbust]

Last I checked, all of flying machine technology in MC is based on that kind of interaction, so it should definitely work

Bi-directional flying machine CA when (either 180 or 90 degrees apart)? Maybe with fewer states so that it can be rule-tabled

Yes, perhaps before we start the redstone CA we can make add other directional pistons or sticky ones.

Maybe. adding Sticky Pistons to udirmcslime should also be possible

I think we can use the same slime states for pulling right and pushing right and vice versa.