Catagolue Oddities

[confocaloid]

https://catagolue.hatsya.com/object/xq9 ... 5553/b3s23 seems to be the same pattern as https://catagolue.hatsya.com/object/xq9 ... yh33/b3s23.
I had both patterns identified on Catagolue's "Objects" page and both returned the same results.

Here are several other non-canonical apgcodes:
xq96_ya33zy2oozzgg888y94aa4z22gii1y1ggylgo8z0egg01icw1221ym1z0161yag8gzycs010uvwkk8kc8yjggzyn8880e6cyf11x4ei8zyn1ibgzyp1yo11zyokmm122yv8gozyp1yz01zyugo0or4y0g8g0gg0l76wgzyv101y31w1203xq5rzyzyccccc48gyao4ozyzyc444011yc1yboozyzyp696zyzym42248gwg80gy466zyzyj225344403wd0c3
xq96_ya33zy2oozz0oosgy94aa4zw1ojy2ggylo88z4s5h11ecw1221yl1z0323yag8gzyb8880eghewkkkkcyjggzyngcgoa0eyf11xeaizyomfgzyp1zyomgl53ywg0ozyo111yz11zyuoo0c2ey0g8ggggod15wggzyu11011y210110211wf0fzyzycciii48gyao4ozyzydex1yc1yboozyzyp696zyzyn664ogwgggy566zyzyk7554e0311w2771
xq96_ya33zy2oozz0804gy94aa4z011a9hy1ggylocgzkk5025aaw1221z13431yaogzycs08dnne4wmmmcyjggzym1984csa44ye11w4ar4zyog0uzyp10gzyoo4gd3yx8ggzyo121yhgyd11zytg884k264xg888804et2wggzyu111y41y13w67077zyzyccivesogyao4ozyzyc454yf1yboozyzyp696zyzylg068m88gwogy566zyzyj25dc0e0201016041

I guess the actual puzzles are (a) why the object page for the non-canonical apgcode displays any synthesis at all, and (b) why the shown synthesis is completely unrelated:

Code: Select all

#C [[ GRID MAXGRIDSIZE 14 THEME Catagolue ]]
#CSYNTH xq96_y933zy1oozzg8oya4aa4z707y3ggymgoz69992k8w1221yl101z07ycgzybs01h5o80oc8coykggzyg1y1gg8ugicyf11x444ozym1o0h8ym8hzyo1yn121zyoo772ywko8zyo1zytgggcecy0g84w8ep9azyzy111w23y0hvazyzya4k680ogybo4ozyzyb44401yd1yboozyzyo696zyzyl4i48gyb66zyzyi22203443w55553 costs 0 gliders.


#CSYNTH xp120_y064koy1ca23zycoge2zykgggzy6ew96y4hhhzwccyg111zgggyg66z0hhhy4ciwez111zy38e13zy6o8a6y1354c costs 36 gliders (true).
#CLL state-numbering golly
x = 333, y = 54, rule = B3/S23
237bo$189bo45bobo4bo$190b2o44b2o5b2o13bo63bo$189b2o51b2o12b3o51bo
9b3o$255bo54b3o6bo$255b2o56bo5b2o$187b2o52bo70b2o$186bobo52b2o2b3o
$132b2o54bo6b2o43bobo4bo12b2o62b2o$73bo58bo62bo50bo13bo63bo$72bo
57bobo60bobo62bobo61bobo$65bo6b3o55b2o61b2o63b2o62b2o$64b2o$64bobo
$57b3o$59bo271bo$58bo17bo61b3o60b3o62b3o46bobo11bo2bo$76bobo58b3o
60b3o62b3o48b2o3bo7bo2bo$76b2o238bo4bobo6bo$71b3o70bo176b2o$71bo
63bo7bo186bo$72bo60bobo7b3o31bo22b3o62b3o61bo2bo$134b2o42bo22b3o
62b3o60bo2bo$139b3o34b3o152bo$139bo104b2o62b2o$140bo57bo45b2o62b2o
$181b3o15bo$181bo15b3o$114bo67bo82b2o62b2o$115bo149b2o62b2o$113b3o
86b3o102bo$119b2o56b3o22bo39b3o61bo2bo$44bo64b3o7bobo56b3o22bo39b
3o60bo2bo$45bo65bo7bo188bo$43b3o64bo205b2o$39b2o267bo6bobo4bo$38bo
bo74b3o60b3o62b3o60bo2bo7bo3b2o$40bo73b3o60b3o62b3o61bo2bo11bobo$
6bo300bo$5bo$5b3o$obo$b2o39b3o9b2o67b2o61b2o63b2o62b2o$bo42bo8bobo
66bobo60bobo62bobo61bobo$43bo9bo68bo62bo64bo13bo49bo$52b2o67b2o61b
2o6bo56b2o12bo4bobo42b2o$192bobo68b3o2b2o$192b2o75bo55b2o$254b2o
62b2o5bo$255bo63bo6b3o$190b2o60b3o12b2o47b3o9bo$189b2o61bo13b2o5b
2o41bo$191bo76bo4bobo$273bo!

[iddi01]

Crossposting the negative growth oddity:

Weirdest apgcode linear growth: yl130_1_-4_701e9d64c6526dcf9ba48abb7962c2ec (is this a bug or something?)

Code: Select all

x = 16, y = 16, rule = B3-n/S1e2-a3-e4e
bboobobbbbooobbo$
bobobboboobboboo$
obobboobobbobobo$
obbobboobobbbbbb$
boobobooobooobbb$
oboooooooooobobb$
bbbbobbobbboobbo$
oobbobbbbbbbobbo$
oooobobooobbooob$
obobbbboboobbobo$
boooobobooobbbbo$
bbbbbbooboboobob$
boooobobobbbbobo$
bboobobbbbbooobb$
bbobobbboobbbboo$
ooboobobbbobbobo!

Also, this is an apgsearch oddity, but i think it still belongs here:

apgerr.png (38.86 KiB) Viewed 18011 times

When left running on an unapgsearchable rule for several hours, it starts repeatedly outputting the stuff in the image.

[hotdogPi]

Someone on Discord has found that the "B0 indicator" for determining whether odd periods can exist or not is determined solely by whether the rule begins with "b0". https://catagolue.hatsya.com/object/xp2 ... tawayazav2 is a false positive despite being a custom rule. I would guess B130/anything is a false negative, but I haven't checked.

[LaundryPizza03]

3c/3d misidentified as xq6 by apgsearch: object page

Code: Select all

x = 10, y = 9, rule = R4,C6,M1,S9..11,B8..9,NM
4.2D$C3.2D$C2.3D$C2A6D$C2AD.4D$C2A3D$6A$AC4A3.C$4A4C!

[May13]

3c/3d misidentified as xq6 by apgsearch: object page

Code: Select all

x = 10, y = 9, rule = R4,C6,M1,S9..11,B8..9,NM
4.2D$C3.2D$C2.3D$C2A6D$C2AD.4D$C2A3D$6A$AC4A3.C$4A4C!

No, this is a true p6 spaceship with glide-reflect symmetry:

Code: Select all

x = 39, y = 10, rule = R4,C6,M1,S9..11,B8..9,NM
31.C$4.2D28.2D$C3.2D24.C3.2D$C2.3D11.E4.E7.C3.2D$C2A6D7.E6.E6.C2A6D$C
2AD.4D6.10E5.C2AD.4D$C2A3D10.E6.E6.3A4D$6A11.E4.E7.6A$AC4A3.C20.AC4A$
4A4C22.3A5C!

So this is a LifeViewer bug, not Catagolue/apgsearch.
(possibly because generations 2 and 5 have the same set of state 1 cells, then why is my pattern identified as p6?)

[confocaloid]

The following may be considered either an actual bug or an "oddity" to keep in mind, depending on one's viewpoint.

The line "Objects per contributor since 2015-02-27" above the chart is always the same, regardless of the CA (for example, Speciation was not apgsearched before May 2024). That line does not carry any knowledge about the history of exploration of the specific ruleset.

I would expect either the actual date of the first submitted haul (instead of "2015-02-27") or absence of any specific date on the census page.

Related discussion:

[...]
by the way i checked catagolue to see if my breeder was known and actually the entire rule was known since 2015, [...]

Correction: not really since 2015 (assuming the CA under discussion is this). The first submitted C1 haul is this haul (LaundryPizza03, 2024-03-27 02:12:45).
[...]

[confocaloid]

Something seems to prevent processing of a RLE in the readsynth queue:

Code: Select all

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
70b2o$70bobo$72bo4b2o$68b4ob2o2bo2bo$68bo2bobobobob2o$71bobobobo$72b2o
bobo$76bo2$62b2o$63bo7b2o$63bobo5b2o$64b2o2$93bo$91b3o$79bobo8bo$80b2o
8b2o$80bo$74b2o$74bo23b2o$75b3o21bo$77bo21bob2o$43bo47b2o4b3o2bo$42bob
o3b2o41b2o3bo3b2o$41bo2bo3bo47b4o$41bobob2obo33b2o15bo$40b2obobobo33bo
bo12b3o$38bo2bob2o36bo13bo$38b2o40b2o14b5o$55b3o42bo$15b2o40bo40bo$2o
12bo2bo38bo3b2o36b2o$bo13b2o43bo$bobo24b2o28bobo$2b2o24bo3b2o6b2o16b2o
10bo$8bo12bo8bo2bo6b2o28b3o$7bobo10bobo6b3o2b2o37bo$8bo11bobo9b2o2bo
35b2o$2b2o17bo7b3o2bobo50b2o$bobo25bo2b2obo4b2o34bo10bo$bo28b2o3bobo2b
2o16b2o16bobo5b2obo$2o31b2ob2o19b3o16b2o5bo2bo$34bo21b3obo23b2o$33bo2b
2o17b3obo9b2o$8b2o24b2obo18b4o9b2o$8bo4b2o42b2o$9bo3b2o26bo$10bo29bobo
$8bob5o21bo4bo14b2o3bo$7bobo4bo8bo12b3o17bo3bobo$7bobo2bo9bobo14bo17bo
3bobo$8bo3b2o8bobo13b2o18bo3bobob2o$23bo26b2o4bob4o2bob2o$18b2o30bobo
3b2o3bobo$17bobo32bo6bobob2ob2o$17bo34b2o2b3obo3bobo$16b2o38bo2bo4bobo
10b2o$12bo44b2o6bo11b2o$12b3o24bo8b2o$15bo21b5o6bobo$14b2o21b2o2b2o7bo
$40bo9b2o$5b2o$4bobo$4bo$b2obo7bo$2bobob2o2b3o25b2ob2o$2bobob2o2b2o22b
2o3bob2o2b2o$b2obo7bo21bo2bobo6bo$bo2b4o3bo10b2o12b2ob7o$2b2o3bo3bo10b
obo13bo$4b2o18bo13bob4o$4bo13bo5b2o13b2o2bo$6bo12bo$5b2o10b3o!
Checking periodicity with exponent 10...
Checking periodicity with exponent 12...
Checking periodicity with exponent 14...
Checking periodicity with exponent 16...
Oscillation not detected (try increasing maxexp?)
# Not a gun
# Filtering with radius 5
# Engulfing yzydg88baabp6o80gzyzyd11w33032w11zyzy82egoy14caoccyhckggzyk33y58e1eo0o4a5lmw4s0gyqoge2x1zyv33034al913kpy011y4g06a8oy7696y3oimggciczysooy5ocsogy8121wog88gye66w1aczyags2552y042eyb16731yaccw6icja8kkoy3gydoge2zyp354cy5g8oycccx122d926ioy1343y6252xo8gzwoimggyaggye23wca8ybggyg2552y832z0ggcaaq1wggy3643yrgs246p7gf201z320f91y011y964koyq1zy5o8a6y4634zyqccy162sgzyigg0s2s0s4owgzyi1023w1169d11
# processing src=xg13332_yzydg88baabp6o80gyf153zyzyd11w33032w11zyzy82egoy3696yickggzyk33y58e1eo0o4a5lmw4s0gyqoge2x1zyv33034al913kpy011y4g06a8oy7696y3oimggciczysooym121wog88gye66w1aczyags2552wggyxccw6icja8kkoy3gydoge2zyh103y1354cy5g8oycccx122d926ioy1343y6252xo8gzwoimggyaggye23ygggyg2552y832z0ggcaaq1wggy3643yrgs246p7gf201z320f91y011y964koyq1zy5o8a6zyqccy162sgzyigg0s2s0s4owgzyi1023w1169d11, dst=xg3333_ys32acxca23zyw8k8y2o8g08kk8zysgy9oo1vg4cy14s0gy584szyr343ygok46w11zyw2552y68kk8zyuo80g0ggzyvc9jcjc3og8gyiggzyo8oy3122156065x2egoyaohkm88gzyj8kiabqy233x33y1252y2153x33x660v0f9zyko8b5yro8y3321zytsg8yd354cx113zyu8oy4gy06248q6geiczy5c88gyf311y36d1jgw25akjaqhgzxo8y211yp2h5j1y16606221z354rak044364y3ggya178cy111zwc4l452y1ac4x1074yagggydcczx11yhca23y4210g8gzyzc4521zya8e13y166zygoggs2uge1u08ozyi643y011...

For reference, below is the current readsynth content as of the time I'm writing this:

Code: Select all

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
71bo$69b2o$70b2o3$160bo$63bo6bo89bobo29bo$20bo43bo3b2o90b2o28bobo$20bo
bo39b3o4b2o85bo34b2o6bo$20b2o135bo39b2o$155b3o40b2o$15bo49bo94b2o31bo
50bobo$14bo50bobo92bobo31b2o49b2o5bo$14b3o48b2o93bo32b2o3b2o6bo38bo6bo
bo$3bo52bo48bo46bo45bo6bo46b2o$3b3o50b3o46b3o6bo37b3o44b3o3b3o40b2o$6b
o52bo48bo5bobo38bo46bo7bo37bo$o2b2obo46bo2b2obo10bo31bo2b2obo5b2o33bo
2b2obo40bo2b2obo6b2o31bo2b2obo$4obo47b4obo10bo32b4obo41b4obo41b4obo7bo
bo30b4obo3b3o3b2o$19bo49b3o179bo4b2o$2o15b2o34b2o47b2o5b2o6bo31b2o45b
2o44b2o8bo5bo$o2b2o13b2o33bo2b2o44bo2b2obobo5bo32bo2b2ob2o39bo2b2ob2o
38bo2b2ob2o$b2obo8b3o38b2ob3o5b3o35b2ob2o8b3o31b2ob2obo40b2ob2obo39b2o
b2obo$13bo46bo4bo$14bo44b2o5bo47bo$113b2o$113bobo$68b2o$68bobo$12b2o
54bo$11b2o$13bo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
10b2o$7b2o2bo$5b3ob2o$4bo$5b3ob2o$7bob2o2$44b2o$3bo24bo15b2o5b2o7b2o$
2bobo23b3o20b2o7bo$2bobo26bo26bobo$b2ob2o8b2o14b2o26b2o$bo12b2o$2bob2o
58b2o$obob2o58bo$2o22bo37bobo$22bo3bo35b2o$21bo$20b2o5b2o$19bo8bo$21bo
bo4bo$11b2o5bo2bo3b3o$2b2o7b2o5b2o2bo$bobo16b3o41b2o$bo19bo38b2obobo$
2o58b2obo$64bo$6b2o52b2ob2o$5bobo53bobo$5bo7b2o46bobo$4b2o7b2o5b2o40bo
$20b2o7b2o$25b2o4b4o$25b2o2b2ob3o20b2obo$29bo25b2ob3o$61bo$55b2ob3o$
39bo14bo2b2o$31bo6bobo13b2o$30bobo6bo$29bo3bo$30bo3bo7bo$31bo3bo5bobo$
32bo3bo2b2o2b2o$33bobo3b2ob2o$34bo3b2ob3o$38b3o14bo$39bobo14bo$40b2o
12b3o!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
86bo$84bobo$85b2o7$41bo$8bo30bobo6bo43bo5bo$7bobo30b2o5bobo41bobo3bob
o$7bobo37bobo41bobo3bobo$8bob2o25b2o9bob2o22bobo15bo5bob2o$6bobo2bo24b
obo7bobo2bo23b2o19bobo2bo$6b2obo28bo7b2obo25bo11bo8b2obo$9b2o38b2o37b
o10b2o$9bo39bo36b3o10bo$7bobo36b2obo32b2o12b2obo$2bo4b2o36bo2bo32bobo
11bo2bo$3b2o40b2o36bo11b2o$2b2o3$bo$b2o81b3o$obo83bo$85bo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
18bo$16b3o$15bo$15b2o12b2o3b2o$30bo3bo5b2o$11b2o17bobobo4bobo$9bo18b2o
bobob2o2bo$9b3o15bobobobobobob2o$10bo15bo4bobo3bobo$26bobo2bobobobobo$
24bobo5b2o3b2ob2o$14bo8bobobobo2b5obobo$13b2o7bo2bobobobo6bobo$20b3obo
b4o2b7ob2o$19bo4bo5bobo6bo$20b3obo4b2o2bo2b2obo$22bo2bobo3b2o3bobo$11b
o15b4o$10b3o17bo$10b3o14bo2bobo$2o14bo6b2obo4b2o$2o13bobo5b2o$15bobo$
16b2o13b2o$24b2o4bo2bo$24b2o4bobobo$4bo26bob3o$2b2o4b2o23b3o$2b2o2b2ob
3o$3bo8bo$8b2obo$3bobo3bobo29b2o$3bob2o34bobo$2bo8bo31bo$3b3ob2o2b2o
30bob2o$5b2o4b2o27b2obobo$10bo29b2obobo$34b2o7bob2o$24b2o7bo2bo3b4o2bo
$17b2o4bobo8b2o4bo3b2o$16bo2bo3bo18b2o$15bobobo2b2o19bo$14b3obo22bo$
14b3o24b2o4$7b2o10b2o$6bobo9bo2bo$6bo12b2o$3b2obo7bo$4bobob2o2b3o$4bob
ob2o2b2o$3b2obo7bo$3bo2b4o3bo10b2o$4b2o3bo3bo10bobo$6b2o18bo$6bo13bo5b
2o$7bo13bo$6b2o11b3o!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
b2o8b2o$b2o9bo7bo$12bobo4bobo12b2o$13b2o5bo13b3o$2obo5b2o23b2obo$bobo
5b2o5b3o17bobo$2bo13bo18bo2bo$b2o14bo18b2o3b2o$b2o38b2o$b2o38b2o$15b2o
23b2o$5bo6bobobo19bo2b2obo$6bo3b2ob3o20b2ob2ob3o$b2o3bo4b2o23bo8bo$o2b
o33b2o2b2o2bo$obo25b2o8bo2bobob2o$bob2o23b2o7bo5bo$2b3o13bo17bo5b2o$3b
2o12bobo16b2o5bob2o$18bo24bobo$36b2o2b2obobo$36b2o3bob2o$41bo$40b2o$
47b2o$47bobo$49bo$49bob2o$46b2obobo$46b2obobo$40b2o7bob2o$30b2o7bo2bo
3b4o2bo$23b2o4bobo8b2o4bo3b2o$22bo2bo3bo18b2o$21bobobo2b2o19bo$20b3obo
22bo$20b3o24b2o4$13b2o10b2o$12bobo9bo2bo$12bo12b2o$9b2obo7bo$10bobob2o
2b3o$10bobob2o2b2o$9b2obo7bo$9bo2b4o3bo10b2o$10b2o3bo3bo10bobo$12b2o
18bo$12bo13bo5b2o$13bo13bo$12b2o11b3o!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
60b2o$60bo$58bobo$21b2o11bo19b2o2b2o$21b2o10bobo18b2o$33bobo2b2o3bo$
32b2ob2o2bo2bobo$36bobo3bobo8b2o$32b2obo2b4obo9b2o$32b2obobo3bo17b2o$
36bobo3bo16b2o$37bobo3bo$38bo3b2o2$57b2o$57b2o$29b2o$29b2o$14b2o$13bo
2bo$12bob2o$12bo$11b2o$26b2o32b2o$11b2o13bo33b2o$4b2o5b2o14b3o24b2o$4b
2o5b2o16bo24b2o$11b3o$11bo2bo$5bo5bo3bo16bo23b2o$4bobo9b4o12b3o14b2o5b
2o$2ob2ob2o6bob4o15bo13b2o$2o5bo7bo18b2o$6b2o41b2o$49bo$9b2o35b2obo$8b
o2bo33bo2bo$8bobo35b2o$8bo22b2o$4bo26b2o$3bo6b2o$3b2o5b2o37bo$7bo2b2o
36bobo$8bobo7b2o3bo24bobo$8b3o7bo3bobo22b2obob2o$b2o6bo9bo3bobo20bo3bo
bobo$b2o17bo3bobob2o13bob5o3bobo$7b2o9bob4o2bob2o12bo2bo6b3obo$7b2o8bo
bo3bobo19b2o2b2obo2bo$17bobo2bo2b2ob2o20bobo$18bo3b2o2bobo14bobo3bobo$
6b2o18bobo13bo2bobobobo2bo$2b2o2b2o19bo13bob2o3bo2bob2o$bobo13b2o22bo
3b3o3bo$bo14bo2bo20b2o3bo4b2o$2o13bobobo$14b3obo$14b3o4$7b2o10b2o$6bob
o9bo2bo$6bo12b2o$3b2obo7bo$4bobob2o2b3o$4bobob2o2b2o$3b2obo7bo$3bo2b4o
3bo10b2o$4b2o3bo3bo10bobo$6b2o18bo$6bo13bo5b2o$7bo13bo$6b2o11b3o!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
39bo$37b5o$36bo5bo$25b2o10b3o2bo$26bo13bob2o$26bobo10b2o3bo$27b2o2bo2b
o3bo2bobo$30bo8b3ob2o$30bo6bo$30bo8b3ob2o$31bo2bo3bo2bobo$39b2o3bo$11b
2o27bob2o5b2o$b2o8bobo23b3o2bo5bobo$2bo10bo10bo11bo5bo7bo$bo10b3o8bobo
11b5o$b2o8b3o10bo14bo$3bo5b2obob2o$b3o3b3ob5o$o5b3o4b2o$2o$49b2o$12bo
15b2o19bo$10bobob3o12bo17bobo$8b3o3b4obo6b3o18b2o$10bo8bo6bo$4b2o4b2ob
o5bo7b2o3b2o$4b2o5bobo14bo3b2o$12bo14bo$17b2o8b2o$17b2o30b2o$42b2o5b2o
$42b2o2$37bo$36bobo$36b2o6b2o$44bo$45b3o$47bo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
150$152.A$153.2A$152.2A9.A$163.A.A$163.2A2$160.A$160.A.A4.2A$160.2A5.A.A$167.A7$159.A$158.2A$158.A.A!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
154$160.A$161.A$159.3A5$169.3A$154.A14.A$152.A.A15.A$153.2A2$165.A$155.A8.2A$155.2A7.A.A$154.A.A!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
151$169.A$168.A$168.3A6$156.A$154.A.A$148.2A5.2A$149.2A$148.A2$159.3A$159.A$160.A2$162.A$161.2A$161.A.A!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
39bo$37b5o$36bo5bo$25b2o10b3o2bo$26bo13bob2o$26bobo8b2obo3bo$27b2o8b2o
2bobo$31b4o3b4ob2o$31b4o$31b4o3b4ob2o$37b2o2bobo$37b2obo3bo$11b2o27bob
2o$b2o8b2o24b3o2bo$2bo17bo2bo12bo5bo$bo17bo2b3o12b5o4b2o$b2o17bo4bo13b
o5bo2bo$3bo8b2o6bo3bo20bobobo$b3o7bobo7bo24bob3o$o10bo36b3o$2o9bobo$
12b2o$28b2o$29bo14b2o10b2o$19bo6b3o14bo2bo9bobo$19bo6bo17b2o12bo$4b2o
13bo7b2o21bo7bob2o$4b2o22bo21b3o2b2obobo$27bo23b2o2b2obobo$17b2o8b2o
21bo7bob2o$17b2o20b2o10bo3b4o2bo$38bobo10bo3bo3b2o$38bo18b2o$37b2o5bo
13bo$43bo13bo$43b3o11b2o!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
70b2o$70bobo$72bo4b2o$68b4ob2o2bo2bo$68bo2bobobobob2o$71bobobobo$72b2o
bobo$76bo2$62b2o$63bo7b2o$63bobo5b2o$64b2o2$93bo$91b3o$79bobo8bo$80b2o
8b2o$80bo$74b2o$74bo23b2o$75b3o21bo$77bo21bob2o$43bo47b2o4b3o2bo$42bob
o3b2o41b2o3bo3b2o$41bo2bo3bo47b4o$41bobob2obo33b2o15bo$40b2obobobo33bo
bo12b3o$38bo2bob2o36bo13bo$38b2o40b2o14b5o$55b3o42bo$15b2o40bo40bo$2o
12bo2bo38bo3b2o36b2o$bo13b2o43bo$bobo24b2o28bobo$2b2o24bo3b2o6b2o16b2o
10bo$8bo12bo8bo2bo6b2o28b3o$7bobo10bobo6b3o2b2o37bo$8bo11bobo9b2o2bo
35b2o$2b2o17bo7b3o2bobo50b2o$bobo25bo2b2obo4b2o34bo10bo$bo28b2o3bobo2b
2o16b2o16bobo5b2obo$2o31b2ob2o19b3o16b2o5bo2bo$34bo21b3obo23b2o$33bo2b
2o17b3obo9b2o$8b2o24b2obo18b4o9b2o$8bo4b2o42b2o$9bo3b2o26bo$10bo29bobo
$8bob5o21bo4bo14b2o3bo$7bobo4bo8bo12b3o17bo3bobo$7bobo2bo9bobo14bo17bo
3bobo$8bo3b2o8bobo13b2o18bo3bobob2o$23bo26b2o4bob4o2bob2o$18b2o30bobo
3b2o3bobo$17bobo32bo6bobob2ob2o$17bo34b2o2b3obo3bobo$16b2o38bo2bo4bobo
10b2o$12bo44b2o6bo11b2o$12b3o24bo8b2o$15bo21b5o6bobo$14b2o21b2o2b2o7bo
$40bo9b2o$5b2o$4bobo$4bo$b2obo7bo$2bobob2o2b3o25b2ob2o$2bobob2o2b2o22b
2o3bob2o2b2o$b2obo7bo21bo2bobo6bo$bo2b4o3bo10b2o12b2ob7o$2b2o3bo3bo10b
obo13bo$4b2o18bo13bob4o$4bo13bo5b2o13b2o2bo$6bo12bo$5b2o10b3o!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
obo81bobo$b2o81b2o$bo83bo14$38bobo$39b2o$39bo4bo$43bo$43b3o3$209bo$
207b2o$203bo4b2o$24bo37bo138bobo$25b2o33b2o140b2o$24b2o7bobo25b2o73bo$
28bo4b2o102b2o56bobo7bo$29b2o3bo30bobo68b2o58b2o5b2o$28b2o27b2o6b2o76b
2ob2o43bo4bo7b2o$52bo3b2o8bo73b2o2bobo2b2o41bo$17bo34b2o4bo80bob2obobo
b2obo38b3o$18b2o31bobo84bo4bo3bo4bo56b2o$17b2o120b3o7b3o44b2ob2o7b2o$
135bo5bobo3bobo47bobo2b2o6bo$68b2o66bo5b2o3b2o46bobobob2obo$33bobo31b
2o65b3o58b2o3bo4bo$28bo4b2o34bo69b2o61b3o$20bo8b2o3bo103bobo59bobo$20b
2o6b2o27b2o81bo58bobo$19bobo30bo3b2o133b2o7bo$52b2o4bo131bobo$24b2o25b
obo7b2o129bo$25b2o33b2o$24bo37bo6$41b3o$43bo$42bo4bo$46b2o$46bobo14$bo
83bo$b2o81b2o$obo81bobo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
16bo42bo$8bo5b2o41b2o$9bo5b2o41b2o$7b3o2$60bo$2o11bo34b2o9b2o31b2o4bo$
o2bob2o6bobo32bo2bob2o4bobo30bo2bobobo7bo$2b2obobo5b2o35b2obobo38b2obo
2bo4b2o$3bo2b2o43bo2b2o39bo2b2o6b2o$3bo47bo43bo$4b4o44b3obo39b3obo$5bo
2bo44bob2o40bob2o8bo$3bo3b2o5bo36bo43bo13bobo$3b2o7b2o37b2o42b2o7b3o2b
2o$13b2o89bo$105bo2$15b2o$15bobo$6b2o7bo$5bobo$7bo24$85bobo$85b2o$86bo
4$86bo$84b2o$85b2o3$83b2o$82b2o$84bo2$26bo$24b2o69bo$25b2o67bo$94b3o2$
27bo$15b2o9b2o$15bo2bob2o4bobo45b2o4bo$17b2obobo51bo2bobobo$18bo2b2o
53b2obo2bo$18bo58bo2b2o$19b4o54bo$20bo2bo54b4o$18bo3b2o55bo2bo$18b2o
57bo3b2o$77b2o10$96b3o$96bo$97bo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
17$135bo$133b2o$129bo4b2o$127bobo$128b2o2$121bobo7bo$9bo5bo106b2o5b2o$
10bo3bo45b2o55bo4bo7b2o$8b3o3b3o42bobo3bobo50bo$61bo3b2o49b3o$66bo68b
2o$12b2o55b2o51b2ob2o7b2o$11bobo54bo2bo51bobo2b2o6bo$13bo5b2o47bobo2b
2o46bobobob2o$18bo2bo44bobobob2o47b2o3bo3bo$18bobo2b2o41b2o3bo3bo51bob
2o$17b2obob2o48bob2o48b3o$21bo3bo43b3o52bo$22bob2o43bo47b2o$19b3o94bob
o$19bo98bo2$121b2o$121bobo$121bo!

Possibly relevant: viewtopic.php?p=186890#p186890 viewtopic.php?p=151466#p151466

[May13]

Why Catagolue is not accepting this component? (I sent it 2 or 3 times but after updates nothing happened)

Code: Select all

x = 12, y = 17, rule = B3/S23
8bo$7bobo$7bobo$8bob2o$6bobo2bo$6b2obo$9b2o$9bo$7bobo$2bo4b2o$3b2o$2b
2o3$bo$b2o$obo!

This is necessary for synthesis of xs22_08u1i4oz32cjc1:

Code: Select all

x = 102, y = 28, rule = B3/S23
86bo$84bobo$85b2o7$41bo$8bo30bobo6bo43bo5bo$7bobo30b2o5bobo41bobo3bobo
$7bobo37bobo41bobo3bobo$8bob2o25b2o9bob2o22bobo15bo5bob2o$6bobo2bo24bo
bo7bobo2bo23b2o19bobo2bo$6b2obo28bo7b2obo25bo11bo8b2obo$9b2o38b2o37bo
10b2o$9bo39bo36b3o10bo$7bobo36b2obo32b2o12b2obo$2bo4b2o36bo2bo32bobo
11bo2bo$3b2o40b2o36bo11b2o$2b2o3$bo$b2o81b3o$obo83bo$85bo!

Edit: and anything from viewtopic.php?p=186908#p186908
Edit 2: I think this is the reason (failed job):

error.png (85.75 KiB) Viewed 17792 times

(Edit: This process has been going on for almost 4 hours.)
Readsynth:

Code: Select all

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
71bo$69b2o$70b2o3$160bo$63bo6bo89bobo29bo$20bo43bo3b2o90b2o28bobo$20bo
bo39b3o4b2o85bo34b2o6bo$20b2o135bo39b2o$155b3o40b2o$15bo49bo94b2o31bo
50bobo$14bo50bobo92bobo31b2o49b2o5bo$14b3o48b2o93bo32b2o3b2o6bo38bo6bo
bo$3bo52bo48bo46bo45bo6bo46b2o$3b3o50b3o46b3o6bo37b3o44b3o3b3o40b2o$6b
o52bo48bo5bobo38bo46bo7bo37bo$o2b2obo46bo2b2obo10bo31bo2b2obo5b2o33bo
2b2obo40bo2b2obo6b2o31bo2b2obo$4obo47b4obo10bo32b4obo41b4obo41b4obo7bo
bo30b4obo3b3o3b2o$19bo49b3o179bo4b2o$2o15b2o34b2o47b2o5b2o6bo31b2o45b
2o44b2o8bo5bo$o2b2o13b2o33bo2b2o44bo2b2obobo5bo32bo2b2ob2o39bo2b2ob2o
38bo2b2ob2o$b2obo8b3o38b2ob3o5b3o35b2ob2o8b3o31b2ob2obo40b2ob2obo39b2o
b2obo$13bo46bo4bo$14bo44b2o5bo47bo$113b2o$113bobo$68b2o$68bobo$12b2o
54bo$11b2o$13bo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
10b2o$7b2o2bo$5b3ob2o$4bo$5b3ob2o$7bob2o2$44b2o$3bo24bo15b2o5b2o7b2o$
2bobo23b3o20b2o7bo$2bobo26bo26bobo$b2ob2o8b2o14b2o26b2o$bo12b2o$2bob2o
58b2o$obob2o58bo$2o22bo37bobo$22bo3bo35b2o$21bo$20b2o5b2o$19bo8bo$21bo
bo4bo$11b2o5bo2bo3b3o$2b2o7b2o5b2o2bo$bobo16b3o41b2o$bo19bo38b2obobo$
2o58b2obo$64bo$6b2o52b2ob2o$5bobo53bobo$5bo7b2o46bobo$4b2o7b2o5b2o40bo
$20b2o7b2o$25b2o4b4o$25b2o2b2ob3o20b2obo$29bo25b2ob3o$61bo$55b2ob3o$
39bo14bo2b2o$31bo6bobo13b2o$30bobo6bo$29bo3bo$30bo3bo7bo$31bo3bo5bobo$
32bo3bo2b2o2b2o$33bobo3b2ob2o$34bo3b2ob3o$38b3o14bo$39bobo14bo$40b2o
12b3o!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
86bo$84bobo$85b2o7$41bo$8bo30bobo6bo43bo5bo$7bobo30b2o5bobo41bobo3bob
o$7bobo37bobo41bobo3bobo$8bob2o25b2o9bob2o22bobo15bo5bob2o$6bobo2bo24b
obo7bobo2bo23b2o19bobo2bo$6b2obo28bo7b2obo25bo11bo8b2obo$9b2o38b2o37b
o10b2o$9bo39bo36b3o10bo$7bobo36b2obo32b2o12b2obo$2bo4b2o36bo2bo32bobo
11bo2bo$3b2o40b2o36bo11b2o$2b2o3$bo$b2o81b3o$obo83bo$85bo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
18bo$16b3o$15bo$15b2o12b2o3b2o$30bo3bo5b2o$11b2o17bobobo4bobo$9bo18b2o
bobob2o2bo$9b3o15bobobobobobob2o$10bo15bo4bobo3bobo$26bobo2bobobobobo$
24bobo5b2o3b2ob2o$14bo8bobobobo2b5obobo$13b2o7bo2bobobobo6bobo$20b3obo
b4o2b7ob2o$19bo4bo5bobo6bo$20b3obo4b2o2bo2b2obo$22bo2bobo3b2o3bobo$11b
o15b4o$10b3o17bo$10b3o14bo2bobo$2o14bo6b2obo4b2o$2o13bobo5b2o$15bobo$
16b2o13b2o$24b2o4bo2bo$24b2o4bobobo$4bo26bob3o$2b2o4b2o23b3o$2b2o2b2ob
3o$3bo8bo$8b2obo$3bobo3bobo29b2o$3bob2o34bobo$2bo8bo31bo$3b3ob2o2b2o
30bob2o$5b2o4b2o27b2obobo$10bo29b2obobo$34b2o7bob2o$24b2o7bo2bo3b4o2bo
$17b2o4bobo8b2o4bo3b2o$16bo2bo3bo18b2o$15bobobo2b2o19bo$14b3obo22bo$
14b3o24b2o4$7b2o10b2o$6bobo9bo2bo$6bo12b2o$3b2obo7bo$4bobob2o2b3o$4bob
ob2o2b2o$3b2obo7bo$3bo2b4o3bo10b2o$4b2o3bo3bo10bobo$6b2o18bo$6bo13bo5b
2o$7bo13bo$6b2o11b3o!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
b2o8b2o$b2o9bo7bo$12bobo4bobo12b2o$13b2o5bo13b3o$2obo5b2o23b2obo$bobo
5b2o5b3o17bobo$2bo13bo18bo2bo$b2o14bo18b2o3b2o$b2o38b2o$b2o38b2o$15b2o
23b2o$5bo6bobobo19bo2b2obo$6bo3b2ob3o20b2ob2ob3o$b2o3bo4b2o23bo8bo$o2b
o33b2o2b2o2bo$obo25b2o8bo2bobob2o$bob2o23b2o7bo5bo$2b3o13bo17bo5b2o$3b
2o12bobo16b2o5bob2o$18bo24bobo$36b2o2b2obobo$36b2o3bob2o$41bo$40b2o$
47b2o$47bobo$49bo$49bob2o$46b2obobo$46b2obobo$40b2o7bob2o$30b2o7bo2bo
3b4o2bo$23b2o4bobo8b2o4bo3b2o$22bo2bo3bo18b2o$21bobobo2b2o19bo$20b3obo
22bo$20b3o24b2o4$13b2o10b2o$12bobo9bo2bo$12bo12b2o$9b2obo7bo$10bobob2o
2b3o$10bobob2o2b2o$9b2obo7bo$9bo2b4o3bo10b2o$10b2o3bo3bo10bobo$12b2o
18bo$12bo13bo5b2o$13bo13bo$12b2o11b3o!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
60b2o$60bo$58bobo$21b2o11bo19b2o2b2o$21b2o10bobo18b2o$33bobo2b2o3bo$
32b2ob2o2bo2bobo$36bobo3bobo8b2o$32b2obo2b4obo9b2o$32b2obobo3bo17b2o$
36bobo3bo16b2o$37bobo3bo$38bo3b2o2$57b2o$57b2o$29b2o$29b2o$14b2o$13bo
2bo$12bob2o$12bo$11b2o$26b2o32b2o$11b2o13bo33b2o$4b2o5b2o14b3o24b2o$4b
2o5b2o16bo24b2o$11b3o$11bo2bo$5bo5bo3bo16bo23b2o$4bobo9b4o12b3o14b2o5b
2o$2ob2ob2o6bob4o15bo13b2o$2o5bo7bo18b2o$6b2o41b2o$49bo$9b2o35b2obo$8b
o2bo33bo2bo$8bobo35b2o$8bo22b2o$4bo26b2o$3bo6b2o$3b2o5b2o37bo$7bo2b2o
36bobo$8bobo7b2o3bo24bobo$8b3o7bo3bobo22b2obob2o$b2o6bo9bo3bobo20bo3bo
bobo$b2o17bo3bobob2o13bob5o3bobo$7b2o9bob4o2bob2o12bo2bo6b3obo$7b2o8bo
bo3bobo19b2o2b2obo2bo$17bobo2bo2b2ob2o20bobo$18bo3b2o2bobo14bobo3bobo$
6b2o18bobo13bo2bobobobo2bo$2b2o2b2o19bo13bob2o3bo2bob2o$bobo13b2o22bo
3b3o3bo$bo14bo2bo20b2o3bo4b2o$2o13bobobo$14b3obo$14b3o4$7b2o10b2o$6bob
o9bo2bo$6bo12b2o$3b2obo7bo$4bobob2o2b3o$4bobob2o2b2o$3b2obo7bo$3bo2b4o
3bo10b2o$4b2o3bo3bo10bobo$6b2o18bo$6bo13bo5b2o$7bo13bo$6b2o11b3o!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
39bo$37b5o$36bo5bo$25b2o10b3o2bo$26bo13bob2o$26bobo10b2o3bo$27b2o2bo2b
o3bo2bobo$30bo8b3ob2o$30bo6bo$30bo8b3ob2o$31bo2bo3bo2bobo$39b2o3bo$11b
2o27bob2o5b2o$b2o8bobo23b3o2bo5bobo$2bo10bo10bo11bo5bo7bo$bo10b3o8bobo
11b5o$b2o8b3o10bo14bo$3bo5b2obob2o$b3o3b3ob5o$o5b3o4b2o$2o$49b2o$12bo
15b2o19bo$10bobob3o12bo17bobo$8b3o3b4obo6b3o18b2o$10bo8bo6bo$4b2o4b2ob
o5bo7b2o3b2o$4b2o5bobo14bo3b2o$12bo14bo$17b2o8b2o$17b2o30b2o$42b2o5b2o
$42b2o2$37bo$36bobo$36b2o6b2o$44bo$45b3o$47bo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
150$152.A$153.2A$152.2A9.A$163.A.A$163.2A2$160.A$160.A.A4.2A$160.2A5.A.A$167.A7$159.A$158.2A$158.A.A!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
154$160.A$161.A$159.3A5$169.3A$154.A14.A$152.A.A15.A$153.2A2$165.A$155.A8.2A$155.2A7.A.A$154.A.A!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
151$169.A$168.A$168.3A6$156.A$154.A.A$148.2A5.2A$149.2A$148.A2$159.3A$159.A$160.A2$162.A$161.2A$161.A.A!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
39bo$37b5o$36bo5bo$25b2o10b3o2bo$26bo13bob2o$26bobo8b2obo3bo$27b2o8b2o
2bobo$31b4o3b4ob2o$31b4o$31b4o3b4ob2o$37b2o2bobo$37b2obo3bo$11b2o27bob
2o$b2o8b2o24b3o2bo$2bo17bo2bo12bo5bo$bo17bo2b3o12b5o4b2o$b2o17bo4bo13b
o5bo2bo$3bo8b2o6bo3bo20bobobo$b3o7bobo7bo24bob3o$o10bo36b3o$2o9bobo$
12b2o$28b2o$29bo14b2o10b2o$19bo6b3o14bo2bo9bobo$19bo6bo17b2o12bo$4b2o
13bo7b2o21bo7bob2o$4b2o22bo21b3o2b2obobo$27bo23b2o2b2obobo$17b2o8b2o
21bo7bob2o$17b2o20b2o10bo3b4o2bo$38bobo10bo3bo3b2o$38bo18b2o$37b2o5bo
13bo$43bo13bo$43b3o11b2o!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
70b2o$70bobo$72bo4b2o$68b4ob2o2bo2bo$68bo2bobobobob2o$71bobobobo$72b2o
bobo$76bo2$62b2o$63bo7b2o$63bobo5b2o$64b2o2$93bo$91b3o$79bobo8bo$80b2o
8b2o$80bo$74b2o$74bo23b2o$75b3o21bo$77bo21bob2o$43bo47b2o4b3o2bo$42bob
o3b2o41b2o3bo3b2o$41bo2bo3bo47b4o$41bobob2obo33b2o15bo$40b2obobobo33bo
bo12b3o$38bo2bob2o36bo13bo$38b2o40b2o14b5o$55b3o42bo$15b2o40bo40bo$2o
12bo2bo38bo3b2o36b2o$bo13b2o43bo$bobo24b2o28bobo$2b2o24bo3b2o6b2o16b2o
10bo$8bo12bo8bo2bo6b2o28b3o$7bobo10bobo6b3o2b2o37bo$8bo11bobo9b2o2bo
35b2o$2b2o17bo7b3o2bobo50b2o$bobo25bo2b2obo4b2o34bo10bo$bo28b2o3bobo2b
2o16b2o16bobo5b2obo$2o31b2ob2o19b3o16b2o5bo2bo$34bo21b3obo23b2o$33bo2b
2o17b3obo9b2o$8b2o24b2obo18b4o9b2o$8bo4b2o42b2o$9bo3b2o26bo$10bo29bobo
$8bob5o21bo4bo14b2o3bo$7bobo4bo8bo12b3o17bo3bobo$7bobo2bo9bobo14bo17bo
3bobo$8bo3b2o8bobo13b2o18bo3bobob2o$23bo26b2o4bob4o2bob2o$18b2o30bobo
3b2o3bobo$17bobo32bo6bobob2ob2o$17bo34b2o2b3obo3bobo$16b2o38bo2bo4bobo
10b2o$12bo44b2o6bo11b2o$12b3o24bo8b2o$15bo21b5o6bobo$14b2o21b2o2b2o7bo
$40bo9b2o$5b2o$4bobo$4bo$b2obo7bo$2bobob2o2b3o25b2ob2o$2bobob2o2b2o22b
2o3bob2o2b2o$b2obo7bo21bo2bobo6bo$bo2b4o3bo10b2o12b2ob7o$2b2o3bo3bo10b
obo13bo$4b2o18bo13bob4o$4bo13bo5b2o13b2o2bo$6bo12bo$5b2o10b3o!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
obo81bobo$b2o81b2o$bo83bo14$38bobo$39b2o$39bo4bo$43bo$43b3o3$209bo$
207b2o$203bo4b2o$24bo37bo138bobo$25b2o33b2o140b2o$24b2o7bobo25b2o73bo$
28bo4b2o102b2o56bobo7bo$29b2o3bo30bobo68b2o58b2o5b2o$28b2o27b2o6b2o76b
2ob2o43bo4bo7b2o$52bo3b2o8bo73b2o2bobo2b2o41bo$17bo34b2o4bo80bob2obobo
b2obo38b3o$18b2o31bobo84bo4bo3bo4bo56b2o$17b2o120b3o7b3o44b2ob2o7b2o$
135bo5bobo3bobo47bobo2b2o6bo$68b2o66bo5b2o3b2o46bobobob2obo$33bobo31b
2o65b3o58b2o3bo4bo$28bo4b2o34bo69b2o61b3o$20bo8b2o3bo103bobo59bobo$20b
2o6b2o27b2o81bo58bobo$19bobo30bo3b2o133b2o7bo$52b2o4bo131bobo$24b2o25b
obo7b2o129bo$25b2o33b2o$24bo37bo6$41b3o$43bo$42bo4bo$46b2o$46bobo14$bo
83bo$b2o81b2o$obo81bobo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
16bo42bo$8bo5b2o41b2o$9bo5b2o41b2o$7b3o2$60bo$2o11bo34b2o9b2o31b2o4bo$
o2bob2o6bobo32bo2bob2o4bobo30bo2bobobo7bo$2b2obobo5b2o35b2obobo38b2obo
2bo4b2o$3bo2b2o43bo2b2o39bo2b2o6b2o$3bo47bo43bo$4b4o44b3obo39b3obo$5bo
2bo44bob2o40bob2o8bo$3bo3b2o5bo36bo43bo13bobo$3b2o7b2o37b2o42b2o7b3o2b
2o$13b2o89bo$105bo2$15b2o$15bobo$6b2o7bo$5bobo$7bo24$85bobo$85b2o$86bo
4$86bo$84b2o$85b2o3$83b2o$82b2o$84bo2$26bo$24b2o69bo$25b2o67bo$94b3o2$
27bo$15b2o9b2o$15bo2bob2o4bobo45b2o4bo$17b2obobo51bo2bobobo$18bo2b2o
53b2obo2bo$18bo58bo2b2o$19b4o54bo$20bo2bo54b4o$18bo3b2o55bo2bo$18b2o
57bo3b2o$77b2o10$96b3o$96bo$97bo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
17$135bo$133b2o$129bo4b2o$127bobo$128b2o2$121bobo7bo$9bo5bo106b2o5b2o$
10bo3bo45b2o55bo4bo7b2o$8b3o3b3o42bobo3bobo50bo$61bo3b2o49b3o$66bo68b
2o$12b2o55b2o51b2ob2o7b2o$11bobo54bo2bo51bobo2b2o6bo$13bo5b2o47bobo2b
2o46bobobob2o$18bo2bo44bobobob2o47b2o3bo3bo$18bobo2b2o41b2o3bo3bo51bob
2o$17b2obob2o48bob2o48b3o$21bo3bo43b3o52bo$22bob2o43bo47b2o$19b3o94bob
o$19bo98bo2$121b2o$121bobo$121bo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
13$25bo$26bo$24b3o$122bo$122bobo$122b2o6bo$24bo103b2o$25b2o102b2o$24b
2o3$38bobo$39b2o$39bo$26bo$27b2o7bo79bo$26b2o9bo73bobo2bobo$35b3o73b2o
3b2o$112bo$40bo$41b2o$40b2o69bo$109b2o$110b2o$84bo$83bo$38bo44b3o$36bo
bo$37b2o10$53bo296bo$54b2o292b2o$53b2o289bo4b2o$342bobo$343b2o$62b3o$
64bo19bo251bobo7bo$63bo19b2o252b2o5b2o$83bobo246bo4bo7b2o$333bo$331b3o
$188bo5bo155b2o$189bo3bo45b2o96b2ob2o7b2o$187b3o3b3o42bobo3bobo91bobo
2b2o6bo$240bo3b2o90bobobob2obo$245bo90b2o3bo4bo$191b2o55b2o93b3o$190bo
bo54bo2bo90bobo$192bo5b2o47bobo2b2o86bobo$197bo2bo44bobobob2obo77b2o7b
o$197bobo2b2o41b2o3bo4bo75bobo$196b2obob2obo47b3o78bo$78bo121bo4bo44bo
bo$73bo4b3o121b3o44bobo$74bo6bo118bobo47bo$72b3o5bo2b2o114bobo$80bob2o
bo114bo$81bo4bo$83b3o$74b2o5bobo$69b3o3b2o3bobo$71bo2bo6bo$70bo12$49b
3o$51bo$50bo3$53b2o$54b2o$53bo$43b2o$44b2o$43bo2$99b3o$99bo$100bo2$43b
o$43b2o$38b2o2bobo$37bobo$39bo2$24bo$24b2o$23bobo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
150$150.A$148.A.A$149.2A$170.A$170.A.A$150.A.A17.2A$151.2A$151.A3$155.2A$156.2A$155.A6$161.2A$161.A.A$161.A!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
150$164.A$163.A$163.3A4$157.A7.A$157.A.A5.A.A$157.2A6.2A$151.A$149.A.A$150.2A$155.2A$156.2A$155.A!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
148$164.A$164.A.A$164.2A5$160.A$160.A.A$160.2A3$154.3A$156.A$155.A3$148.2A$149.2A$148.A11.A$159.2A$159.A.A!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
18bo$17bobo$17bo2bo$18b2o14$5b3o$7bo$6bo3$3o$2bo$bo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
8bo$7bobo$7bobo$8bob2o$6bobo2bo$6b2obo$9b2o$9bo$7bobo$2bo4b2o$3b2o$2b
2o3$bo$b2o$obo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
152$167.A.A$167.2A$168.A5$154.A$155.2A$147.3A4.2A$149.A$148.A$159.A$158.2A$158.A.A3$160.2A$160.A.A$160.A!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
155$162.A.A$163.2A$155.A.A5.A$156.2A$156.A$164.2A$163.2A$165.A$159.3A$152.2A5.A$153.2A5.A$152.A!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
156$159.A6.A$159.A.A2.2A$159.2A4.2A4$151.3A$153.A$152.A8.2A$162.2A$161.A5.2A$167.A.A$167.A!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
13$25bo$26bo$24b3o$122bo$122bobo$122b2o6bo$24bo103b2o$25b2o102b2o$24b
2o3$38bobo$39b2o$39bo$26bo$27b2o7bo79bo$26b2o9bo73bobo2bobo$35b3o73b2o
3b2o$112bo$40bo$41b2o$40b2o69bo$109b2o$110b2o$84bo$83bo$38bo44b3o$36bo
bo$37b2o10$53bo296bo$54b2o292b2o$53b2o289bo4b2o$342bobo$343b2o$62b3o$
64bo19bo251bobo7bo$63bo19b2o252b2o5b2o$83bobo246bo4bo7b2o$333bo$331b3o
$188bo5bo155b2o$189bo3bo45b2o96b2ob2o7b2o$187b3o3b3o42bobo3bobo91bobo
2b2o6bo$240bo3b2o90bobobob2obo$245bo90b2o3bo4bo$191b2o55b2o93b3o$190bo
bo54bo2bo90bobo$192bo5b2o47bobo2b2o86bobo$197bo2bo44bobobob2obo77b2o7b
o$197bobo2b2o41b2o3bo4bo75bobo$196b2obob2obo47b3o78bo$78bo121bo4bo44bo
bo$73bo4b3o121b3o44bobo$74bo6bo118bobo47bo$72b3o5bo2b2o114bobo$80bob2o
bo114bo$81bo4bo$83b3o$74b2o5bobo$69b3o3b2o3bobo$71bo2bo6bo$70bo12$49b
3o$51bo$50bo3$53b2o$54b2o$53bo$43b2o$44b2o$43bo2$99b3o$99bo$100bo2$43b
o$43b2o$38b2o2bobo$37bobo$39bo2$24bo$24b2o$23bobo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
2bo$3bo$b3o$99bo$99bobo$99b2o6bo$bo103b2o$2b2o102b2o$b2o3$15bobo$16b2o
$16bo$3bo$4b2o7bo79bo$3b2o9bo73bobo2bobo$12b3o73b2o3b2o$89bo$17bo$18b
2o$17b2o69bo$86b2o$87b2o$61bo$60bo$15bo44b3o$13bobo$14b2o10$30bo296bo$
31b2o292b2o$30b2o289bo4b2o$319bobo$320b2o$39b3o$41bo19bo251bobo7bo$40b
o19b2o252b2o5b2o$60bobo246bo4bo7b2o$310bo$308b3o$165bo5bo155b2o$166bo
3bo45b2o96b2ob2o7b2o$164b3o3b3o42bobo3bobo91bobo2bobo5bo$217bo3b2o90bo
bobob3obo$222bo90b2o3bo4bo$168b2o55b2o93b3o$167bobo54bo2bo90bobo$169bo
5b2o47bobo2bobo86b2o$174bo2bo44bobobob3obo76b2o$174bobo2bobo40b2o3bo4b
o75bobo$173b2obob3obo46b3o78bo$55bo121bo4bo44bobo$50bo4b3o121b3o45b2o$
51bo6bo118bobo$49b3o5bo2bobo114b2o$57bob3obo$58bo4bo$60b3o$51b2o5bobo$
46b3o3b2o4b2o$48bo2bo$47bo12$26b3o$28bo$27bo3$30b2o$31b2o$30bo$20b2o$
21b2o$20bo2$76b3o$76bo$77bo2$20bo$20b2o$15b2o2bobo$14bobo$16bo2$bo$b2o
$obo!

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
63bo$64bo$62b3o9$54bobo$55b2o$55bo$72bo$73bo$71b3o20$77bo$75bobo18bo$
76b2o16bobo$80bo14b2o$81bo3bo$79b3o4b2o$85b2o8$109bo$107bobo$108b2o2$
99bo$100b2o$99b2o2$103bobo$104b2o23b2ob2obo$104bo25bobob2o13bo$129bo
19bobo$129b2obob2o13b2o$130bob2obo$8bobo117bo$8b2o118b2o20b2o$9bo135bo
4bobo$143b2o5bo4b2o$obo141b2o9bobo$b2o152bo$bo$139b3o$139bo$140bo$135b
3o$5b2o130bo$4bobo129bo$6bo4$140b3o$109bo30bo$109b2o30bo$81b2o25bobo2b
3o$80bobo32bo$82bo31bo2$94b3o$96bo23b2o28b3o$95bo23bobo28bo$103b2o16bo
29bo$104b2o$81bo21bo50b2o$81b2o71bobo$80bobo71bo$71b2o$72b2o$71bo24$
200b2o$199b2o$201bo4$78b2o$77bobo$79bo4$71bo110b2o$65b2o4b2o108b2o$64b
obo3bobo110bo$66bo6$58b3o$60bo$59bo4$209b2o$208b2o$210bo41$210bo$208b
2o$209b2o4$59bo$60bo$58b3o6$66bo$64bobo3bobo110bo$65b2o4b2o108b2o$71bo
110b2o4$79bo$77bobo$78b2o4$201bo$199b2o$200b2o24$71bo$72b2o$71b2o$80bo
bo71bo$81b2o71bobo$81bo21bo50b2o$104b2o$103b2o16bo29bo$95bo23bobo28bo$
96bo23b2o28b3o$94b3o2$82bo31bo$80bobo32bo$81b2o25bobo2b3o$109b2o30bo$
109bo30bo$140b3o4$6bo$4bobo129bo$5b2o130bo$135b3o$140bo$139bo$139b3o$b
o$b2o152bo$obo141b2o9bobo$143b2o5bo4b2o$9bo135bo4bobo$8b2o118b2o20b2o$
8bobo117bo$130bob2o$129b2obo16b2o$129bo3bo15bobo$104bo25bob2o15bo$104b
2o22bobobo$103bobo22b2o4bo$133b2o$99b2o$100b2o$99bo2$108b2o$107bobo$
109bo8$85b2o$79b3o4b2o$81bo3bo$80bo14b2o$76b2o16bobo$75bobo18bo$77bo
20$71b3o$73bo$72bo$55bo$55b2o$54bobo9$62b3o$64bo$63bo41$83bo$81b2o$82b
2o2$75bo$76bo$74b3o2$86b2o$85b2o$87bo44$140bo$138b2o$139b2o2$8bo$6bobo
$7b2o2$149bo$149bobo$15bo133b2o$16bo$14b3o4$15bo$16b2o35bobo79bo$15b2o
37b2o79bobo$54bo80b2o2$114bo$113bo$22bo90b3o$23bo$21b3o86bo$56bo9bo43b
obo$57b2o8bo42b2o$56b2o7b3o3$109bobo$109b2o$110bo7$63bo49bo$61bobo48bo
$62b2o48b3o3$95bobo$95b2o$96bo2$58bobo32bo$59b2o30b2o$59bo32b2o2$100bo
$67bo31bo$68b2o29b3o$67b2o3$67bo$65bobo$66b2o4$61bo$62bo$60b3o7$86b2o$
86bo2b2o$88b2obo$92bo$88b2ob2o$88bo$89bob2o$77bo12b2o2bo$75bobo15b2o$
76b2o2$79b2o$69b2o7bobo$68bobo9bo$70bo$84bo$83b2o$83bobo4$89b3o$61b2o
21b3o2bo$60bobo23bo3bo$62bo22bo2$56b3o$58bo23b3o$57bo26bo$83bo24$16bo$
16b2o$15bobo16$28bo$28b2o$27bobo7$bo$b2o$obo108$105bo$103b2o$104b2o2$
97bo$98bo$96b3o2$108b2o$107b2o$109bo44$162bo$160b2o$161b2o2$30bo$28bob
o$29b2o2$171bo$171bobo$37bo133b2o$38bo$36b3o4$37bo$38b2o35bobo79bo$37b
2o37b2o79bobo$76bo80b2o2$136bo$135bo$44bo90b3o$45bo$43b3o86bo$78bo9bo
43bobo$79b2o8bo42b2o$78b2o7b3o3$131bobo$131b2o$132bo7$85bo49bo$83bobo
48bo$84b2o48b3o3$117bobo$117b2o$118bo2$80bobo32bo$81b2o30b2o$81bo32b2o
2$122bo$89bo31bo$90b2o29b3o$89b2o3$89bo$87bobo$88b2o4$83bo$84bo$82b3o
7$108b2o$108bo2b2o$110b2obo$114bo$110b2ob2o$110bo$111bob4o$99bo12b2o2b
o$97bobo$98b2o2$101b2o$91b2o7bobo$90bobo9bo$92bo$106bo$105b2o$105bobo
4$111b3o$83b2o21b3o2bo$82bobo23bo3bo$84bo22bo2$78b3o$80bo23b3o$79bo26b
o$105bo24$38bo$38b2o$37bobo16$50bo$50b2o$49bobo7$23bo$23b2o$22bobo!

[Vort]

Something seems to prevent processing of a RLE in the readsynth queue:

I started digging this problem once figured out that my 9999 gun did not appeared in database.
Solution is exactly as stated in logs: "try increasing maxexp".
I changed lifelib\pythlib\pattern.py like so "def oscar(self, maxexp=18, eventual_oscillator=True, verbose=True, return_apgcode=False, allow_guns=True):" and...

Code: Select all

Checking periodicity with exponent 18...
True period: 9999
Stream period: 9999

upd. I created GitLab issue about this problem: https://gitlab.com/hatsya/open-source/c ... /issues/28.

[Vort]

Why Catagolue is not accepting this component? (I sent it 2 or 3 times but after updates nothing happened)

Turned out, gun_9999 triggered not one, but two bugs:
1. Failed gun detection (issue #28);
2. Hang in synthesis processing.

Hang happens at this line:
"out_apgcode = comp.oscar(verbose=False, return_apgcode=True, maxexp=100)["apgcode"]"
https://gitlab.com/parclytaxel/Shinjuku ... ode.py#L60

If I change "verbose=False" to "verbose=True", lines like these can be seen, along with steadily increasing RAM consumption by Python process:

Code: Select all

...
Checking periodicity with exponent 16...
Checking periodicity with exponent 18...
Checking periodicity with exponent 20...
Checking periodicity with exponent 22...
Checking periodicity with exponent 24...
...

[May13]

Something seems to prevent processing of a RLE in the readsynth queue:

I started digging this problem once figured out that my 9999 gun did not appeared in database.
Solution is exactly as stated in logs: "try increasing maxexp".
I changed lifelib\pythlib\pattern.py like so "def oscar(self, maxexp=18, eventual_oscillator=True, verbose=True, return_apgcode=False, allow_guns=True):" and...

Code: Select all

Checking periodicity with exponent 18...
True period: 9999
Stream period: 9999

upd. I created GitLab issue about this problem: https://gitlab.com/hatsya/open-source/c ... /issues/28.

Adam Goucher fixed this problem: https://gitlab.com/hatsya/open-source/c ... 8641bcb8d4
Edit: but what is the problem with this component?

Why Catagolue is not accepting this component? (I sent it 2 or 3 times but after updates nothing happened)

Code: Select all

x = 12, y = 17, rule = B3/S23
8bo$7bobo$7bobo$8bob2o$6bobo2bo$6b2obo$9b2o$9bo$7bobo$2bo4b2o$3b2o$2b
2o3$bo$b2o$obo!

This is necessary for synthesis of xs22_08u1i4oz32cjc1:

Code: Select all

x = 102, y = 28, rule = B3/S23
86bo$84bobo$85b2o7$41bo$8bo30bobo6bo43bo5bo$7bobo30b2o5bobo41bobo3bobo
$7bobo37bobo41bobo3bobo$8bob2o25b2o9bob2o22bobo15bo5bob2o$6bobo2bo24bo
bo7bobo2bo23b2o19bobo2bo$6b2obo28bo7b2obo25bo11bo8b2obo$9b2o38b2o37bo
10b2o$9bo39bo36b3o10bo$7bobo36b2obo32b2o12b2obo$2bo4b2o36bo2bo32bobo
11bo2bo$3b2o40b2o36bo11b2o$2b2o3$bo$b2o81b3o$obo83bo$85bo!

Code: Select all

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
86bo$84bobo$85b2o7$41bo$8bo30bobo6bo43bo5bo$7bobo30b2o5bobo41bobo3bob
o$7bobo37bobo41bobo3bobo$8bob2o25b2o9bob2o22bobo15bo5bob2o$6bobo2bo24b
obo7bobo2bo23b2o19bobo2bo$6b2obo28bo7b2obo25bo11bo8b2obo$9b2o38b2o37b
o10b2o$9bo39bo36b3o10bo$7bobo36b2obo32b2o12b2obo$2bo4b2o36bo2bo32bobo
11bo2bo$3b2o40b2o36bo11b2o$2b2o3$bo$b2o81b3o$obo83bo$85bo!
# Filtering with radius 5
# Engulfing y3ok46k9bkk8zggxocgx11z211
# processing src=xs21_g6p68oz1pgf2, dst=xs24_0g6p68ozg99gf2z11...
xs21_g6p68oz1pgf2>9 -2/5 1//@0r-3 13>xs24_0g6p68ozg99gf2z11
#     ...success.
# Engulfing 0gs2453z64p6p3y0gg0742zx1y2301
# processing src=xs24_0g6p68ozg99gf2z11, dst=xs30_o86p6gw696z02fg99gzy111...
xs24_0g6p68ozg99gf2z11>8 0///6 -2@0f-5 2>xs30_o86p6gw696z02fg99gzy111
#     ...success.
# Engulfing yb654zwg8gkcy7sg8zoi7o4cxgx351y5ocgzw343x343zzyb712
# processing src=xs30_o86p6gw696z02fg99gzy111, dst=xs22_08u1i4oz32cjc1...
xs30_o86p6gw696z02fg99gzy111>22 -6 48 -15/-22 2 -16 16 25 -7//@0l19 3>xs22_08u1i4oz32cjc1
#     ...success.

There is still no synthesis of xs24_0g6p68ozg99gf2z11...
Edit: I will try this pattern:

Code: Select all

x = 132, y = 18, rule = B3/S23
3bo39bo39bo39bo$2bobo37bobo37bobo37bobo$2bobo37bobo37bobo37bobo$2obo
36b2obo36b2obo36b2obo$o2bobo34bo2bobo34bo2bobo34bo2bobo$2bob2o36bob2o
36bob2o36bob2o$b2o38b2o38b2o38b2o$2bo39bo39bo39bo$2bobo37bob2o36bob2o
36bobo$3b2o38bobo37bo2bo36b2o4bo$8bo35bo40b2o40b2o$8bobo41bo75b2o$5b2o
b2o42bobo30b2o$4bobo45b2o31b2o$6bo123bo$49b3o35b3o39b2o$49bo37bo41bobo
$50bo37bo!

I wonder if Catagolue will count this version?
Edit 2: nope. Even the first component is not registered.

[Vort]

In the latest commit, two glider guns of periods 8213 and 9847 (from this post) are not accepted.

While I am on this topic, by the way, I want to repeat the request of having this issue resolved. There are still many slots in the four-digit range to be filled, and rejecting gun periods higher than 8192 (?) but below 10000 contradicts that purpose.

This problem was fixed in commit f7dadbc7. I resubmitted your 2 guns and they should appear in Catagolue in 2 hours.
It's sad it took 2 years to do this, but it is nice that 14..9999 collection now have possibility to be completed.

[vilc]

Catagolue's update process is again broken, because a gun with period 173 x 5^13 (if I counted correctly) was submitted. It causes the same error as the p9999 gun a few days ago. I don't know if it is a spam or oversight, but it seems worth having a reliable security check for this. Perhaps requiring the period of the gun to be given in a rle comment and adapting the checks consequently ?

[confocaloid]

Catagolue's update process is again broken, because a gun with period 173 x 5^13 (if I counted correctly) was submitted. It causes the same error as the p9999 gun a few days ago. I don't know if it is a spam or oversight, but it seems worth having a reliable security check for this. Perhaps requiring the period of the gun to be given in a rle comment and adapting the checks consequently ?

Probably the error happens due to spending too much time while trying to determine the period of a very-high-period gun.

Earlier, I submitted several glider guns (after the fix that allowed higher periods); in particular, I tried to submit a period-10253 glider gun, and it reached the update job log, but (as one could expect) it was rejected with the message "Period too large":

Code: Select all

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
57bo11b2o$56bobo11bo$48bo3b2o2bobo$34bo12bobo2bo2b2ob2o$34b3o10bobo3bo
bo11bobo$37bo10bob4o2bob2o$10b2o24b2o12bo3bobob2o4bo2bo3bo$11bo37bo3bo
bo7bobo4bo$5b2o2bo4bo33bo3bobo7b3o$5bo2bob5o33b2o3bo7b2o$2b2obob2o18b
2o33b2o3bo$2bo2bo3b3ob4o10bo38bo$4bob2o3bobo2bo8bobo38b2o$3b2obo18b2o
40bo$6bo$6b2o68b2o7b2o$75bo2bo6b2o$76b2obo$79bo$79b2o$6b2o56b2o$6bo58b
o$3b2obo29b2o24b3o$3bobo30b2o11b2o11bo$49bo$10bo39b3o$10b3o39bo$8b2ob
3o57b2o$9b2obobo55bobo$7b4o3bo55bo$8bo3b2o55b2o$8b5o$10b2o$70b2o$69bo
2bo2b2o11b2o$70b2o2bobo11b2o$72b2o$72bo$4b2o63b2obo2bo$2o3bo63bob2obob
o$o2bobobo65bobo42bo$2b2obob3o60b2o2bo41bobo$4bobo3bo57b3ob2o43b2o$4bo
bo2b2o56bo$5bo14bo47b3ob2o$21bo48bob2o$19b3o$80b2o$80b2o7b2o21b2o$89bo
22bo$87bobo24bo$87b2o5b2o14b5o$95bo13bo$57bobo35bobo12b3o$58b2o36b2o
15bo$58bo8b2o41b4o$67b2o36b2o3bo3b2o$105b2o4b3o2bo$113bob2o$113bo$112b
2o$83bo$82bobo$82bobo19b2o$83b2ob2o16bo$86bo18b3o$83b2obo20bo$81b3obo$
80bo$80b2o2$113b2o$113bo$94b2o19bo$95bo18b2o$95bobo8b2o4bo3b2o$70b2o
24b2o7bo2bo3b4o2bo$69bobo5b2o27b2o7bob2o$69bo7b2o33b2obobo$68b2o42b2ob
obo$115bob2o$82bo18bo13bo$78b2obobo16bobo10bobo$77bobobobo17bo11b2o$
74bo2bobobob2o21b2o$74b4ob2o2bo23bo$78bo4bo18b2o3bob2o$74b2o2bob3o19b
2o2b2obo2bo$74b2o3b2o28bob2o$102b2o5bo$102bo5b2o$104bo$79bo23b2o$77b3o
$76bo$76b2o3$70bo$69bobo$62b2ob2o3bo$60bo2bob2o$60b2o$76bo$65bo2bo6bob
o$65b4o6bobo$62bo13bo$62b5o$66bo$64bo$64b2o7b2ob2o$69b2o2b2obo3b2o$69b
o6bobo2bo$70b7ob2o$77bo$72b4obo$72bo2b2o!
Checking periodicity with exponent 10...
Checking periodicity with exponent 12...
Checking periodicity with exponent 14...
Checking periodicity with exponent 16...
Checking periodicity with exponent 18...
True period: 10253
Stream period: 10253
Period too large

[...]
edit 2: gun_8783 (157x132), gun_9283 (150x127), gun_9973 (192x162) processed in jobs/7039387123

[Vort]

Probably the error happens due to spending too much time while trying to determine the period of a very-high-period gun.

No, gun detection fails instantly at line "if (p < 1000000)" of idgun.py.

...it seems worth having a reliable security check for this. Perhaps requiring the period of the gun to be given in a rle comment and adapting the checks consequently ?

It is possible to add check without creating inconvenience for users - by adding timeouts to appropriate places, or by limiting amount of computations in other way. "maxexp=100" in shinjuku\transcode.py does not look right.

I don't know if it is a spam or oversight...

Or DoS attack.
I was not expecting this vulnerability to be used by someone that fast.
But this is common scenario in cases when bug report is created, but developers don't solve problem in time.

[May13]

Why Catagolue is not accepting this component? (I sent it 2 or 3 times but after updates nothing happened)

Code: Select all

x = 12, y = 17, rule = B3/S23
8bo$7bobo$7bobo$8bob2o$6bobo2bo$6b2obo$9b2o$9bo$7bobo$2bo4b2o$3b2o$2b
2o3$bo$b2o$obo!

This is necessary for synthesis of xs22_08u1i4oz32cjc1:

Code: Select all

x = 102, y = 28, rule = B3/S23
86bo$84bobo$85b2o7$41bo$8bo30bobo6bo43bo5bo$7bobo30b2o5bobo41bobo3bobo
$7bobo37bobo41bobo3bobo$8bob2o25b2o9bob2o22bobo15bo5bob2o$6bobo2bo24bo
bo7bobo2bo23b2o19bobo2bo$6b2obo28bo7b2obo25bo11bo8b2obo$9b2o38b2o37bo
10b2o$9bo39bo36b3o10bo$7bobo36b2obo32b2o12b2obo$2bo4b2o36bo2bo32bobo
11bo2bo$3b2o40b2o36bo11b2o$2b2o3$bo$b2o81b3o$obo83bo$85bo!

I found another case where Catagolue does not show existing synthesis: xs22_4a5pa4oz696221

Code: Select all

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
51bo$52b2o$51b2o2$64bo$64bobo$64b2o$70bo$68b2o$69b2o2$113bo52bo$112b2o
50b2o$109bo2bobo50b2o$2b2o3b2o9bo33b2o3b2o10bo32b2o3b3o42b2o3bo44b2o3b
o$bo2bobo2bo9b2o30bo2bobo2bo8bo32bo2bobo44bo2bobobo42bo2bobobo$2b2o3b
2o9b2o32b2o3b2obo7b3o31b2o3bo44b2o3bo5b2o37b2o3bobo$3bob2o46bob2o3bo
42bob2o46bob2o5b2o5b2o32bob2o2bo3bobo$3bo2bo46bo2bo3b2o41bo2bobo44bo2b
obo5bo3b2o33bo2bobo4b2o$4bo14b2o33bo49bo2b2o45bo2b2o11bo33bo2bo6bo$b3o
16b2o29b3o47b3o47b3o47b3o$bo17bo31bo49bo49bo49bo19bo$163bo57bobo$162b
2o57b2o$61b3o98bobo52b2o$61bo10b3o142bobo$57b2o3bo9bo136b2o6bo$56bobo
14bo135bobo$58bo150bo3$bo217b3o$b2o216bo$obo217bo!
# Filtering with radius 5
# Engulfing 025t28q552y4562z06221ya532zzgco
# processing src=xs22_25t28q552z6221, dst=xs26_25t28q552sgz6221...
xs22_25t28q552z6221>33 -16/-37 5 37 -1//@0r10 10>xs26_25t28q552sgz6221
#     ...success.
# Engulfing y1247wokgy4ca8zc88gz8kn82bkk871y2ck4zyeggzy9s480112za64
# processing src=xs26_25t28q552sgz6221, dst=xs25_0696k4871z8e12156...
xs26_25t28q552sgz6221>53 -2/20 7/36 -10 40 0/4 9 22 -6 23 1@0r12 1>xs25_0696k4871z8e12156
#     ...success.
# Engulfing 265zw1784oa6zx696221e8
# processing src=xs25_0696k4871z8e12156, dst=xs23_2l2c5jz34311074...
xs25_0696k4871z8e12156>1 0///@0l-1 11>xs23_2l2c5jz34311074
#     ...success.
# Engulfing oggy4361zg8eh4m9jx4cax265z011x1y246a
# processing src=xs23_2l2c5jz34311074, dst=xs24_4a5pa4z696221e8...
xs23_2l2c5jz34311074>21 -5/-11 8 -9 1 15 -4//@0F4 -7>xs24_4a5pa4z696221e8
#     ...success.
# Engulfing 25t28q5icxog8z6221w1y21y2sg8zy4s48y1712zyeck4
# processing src=xs24_4a5pa4z696221e8, dst=xs22_4a5pa4oz696221...
xs24_4a5pa4z696221e8>10 4 27 -8/-24 8 8 -2 18 2//@0F11 -6>xs22_4a5pa4oz696221
#     ...success.
# Filtering with radius 8
# Filtering with radius 13
# Filtering with radius 21

(synthesis of xs22_25t28q552z6221 is known)

no_synthesis.png (85.87 KiB) Viewed 17566 times

[rowett]

3c/3d misidentified as xq6 by apgsearch: object page

Code: Select all

x = 10, y = 9, rule = R4,C6,M1,S9..11,B8..9,NM
4.2D$C3.2D$C2.3D$C2A6D$C2AD.4D$C2A3D$6A$AC4A3.C$4A4C!

No, this is a true p6 spaceship with glide-reflect symmetry:

Code: Select all

x = 39, y = 10, rule = R4,C6,M1,S9..11,B8..9,NM
31.C$4.2D28.2D$C3.2D24.C3.2D$C2.3D11.E4.E7.C3.2D$C2A6D7.E6.E6.C2A6D$C
2AD.4D6.10E5.C2AD.4D$C2A3D10.E6.E6.3A4D$6A11.E4.E7.6A$AC4A3.C20.AC4A$
4A4C22.3A5C!

So this is a LifeViewer bug, not Catagolue/apgsearch.

This has been fixed in LifeViewer build 1151.

Code: Select all

x = 10, y = 9, rule = R4,C6,M1,S9..11,B8..9,NM
4.2D$C3.2D$C2.3D$C2A6D$C2AD.4D$C2A3D$6A$AC4A3.C$4A4C!
[[ AUTOIDENTIFY ]]

[Haycat2009]

Help: What should I do if a canonical apgcode contains words that do not allow it to be saved in the lifewiki?

[confocaloid]

Help: What should I do if a canonical apgcode contains words that do not allow it to be saved in the lifewiki?

When adding the wikitext, try to insert a pair of "nowiki" tags inside the problematic substring, and see if that helps:

Code: Select all

b<nowiki></nowiki>uy

Thanks, that worked.

[confocaloid]

Crossposting a bug. The offending non-gun was submitted at some point between 2024-05-25 and 2024-06-05.

[...]
Initially I thought that red spike appeared because of my mistake, but upon further investigation, it turned out to be a bug in Catagolue verification, here is what caused this spike: gun_1650

Code: Select all

#C [[ GRID MAXGRIDSIZE 14 THEME Catagolue ]] 
#CSYNTH gun_1650 costs 2915 cells.
#C period 1650 fullperiod 1650 bbox 53 by 55
#CLL state-numbering golly
x = 53, y = 55, rule = LifeHistory
2B2A4B2A17BA2BA3BA2BA15B$27BA2BA4BA2BA14B$28B5A5BA14B$31BA3BAB2A
14B$44BA2BABA3B$30BA5BA5B2AB3A2BA2B$28B3A12BABA3BA3B$44BAB2ABA3B$
28B2A7B3A7B2A4B$52BA$33BABA16BA$26BA2BABA3BA17B$27BA4BAB2A17B$27BA
4BA20B$29B2A22B$53B$53B$44B2A7B$44B2A7B$53B$20B2A31B$20B2A12BA18B$
33BABA17B$33BABA17B$34BA18B$11BA41B$10BABA40B$9BABA41B$9B2A42B$6B.
14BA31B$4B3.8BA4BABA30B$.B6.7BA4BABA30B$B6.8BA5BA31B$B5.47B$3B3.
47B$3B4.46B$3B3.47B$2B3.48B$2B4.47B$2B6.3B5.12BA24B$B14.12BABA23B$
4B11.12BABA23B$3B2A11.12BA24B$3B2A10.BA36B$4B11.ABA35B$5B11.2A32BA
2B$7B11.2B3A27BA2B$10B2.2B3.33BA2B$40B.12B$53B$16B2A35B$16B2A35B$.
52B$8.4B.25B4.7B2A2B$9.4B4.B2.12B10.7B2A2B!

[...]

[confocaloid]

Actually, the submitted p1650 glider gun was completely valid, with bounding box 57-by-53:

Code: Select all

x = 57, y = 53, rule = LifeHistory
31.2B$7.2A6.A13.6B$8.A6.3A11.7B$8.A.A7.A9.9B$6.2A.A.A5.2A10.9B$6.A2.A
.A5.5B7.10B$8.A.A8.3B6.12B$3.2A2.2A7.7B4.9B.4B$3.A.A2.BAB5.7B2.4B2A3B
4.4B$5.2AB3A4.A12BA2BA2B5.4B$4.A2.AB2A2B.ABA12B2A2B7.4B$4.3A2B2A3BABA
15B9.4B$7.A.2A3.BA18B8.4B$4.2A.2AB2A3.10B.B5.2A9.4B$3.A.3A2B2A4.10B6.
A11.4B$3.A4.B.B8.8B6.3A9.4B$4.5AB7.6B.3BA7.A10.4B$5.A2.A2B6.2A6.B2AB
18.4B$3.A3.A.A2B6.A7.ABAB10.2A6.4B$3.5AB2A4.3A9.4B9.A8.4B$8.3A4.A5.2A
5.4B.2B7.A7.4B$3.2A.ABA10.A2.A5.7B6.2A8.4B$3.2A.2A11.2A.A.AB.8B2A.2AB
2.2A7.4B$21.A.2AB.7B3AB5A2.A7.3BA$21.A3.9BABA2BA2.A.2A3.2A2.BABA$19.
3A3.10BA5B.A.A3.B2A4B2A$18.A6.12B.B2A.A.A4.4B.B$18.2A5.11B3.B.BA.2A4.
4B$15.5B4.8B.B8.A6.4B$12.6B5.2A7B8.A.A6.4B$3.2A6.BA7B2.ABAB2.3B9.2A6.
B3AB$.3A.A4.BABA10BA3.5B15.B3AB$A4.A3.2BABA10B7.2A14.BA3BAB$.3A.2A2.
3BA10B8.A15.7B$3.2A.BAB3.10B5.A4.3A12.2A3B2A$5.B2AB3.8B6.A.A5.A12.7B$
4.3BA2B3.8B5.A.A18.7B$3.AB3.AB4.3B2A3B3.2A.A.2A15.7B$3.A.4A5.BA2BA3B.
2BA2.A.A.A15.5B$4.A10.A2BA7BABA.A.A15.5B$6.A9.BA2B.4BAB.B2.A17.4B$5.
2A8.BAB4.3B2AB3A18.4B$10.B3.2B7.2B.A23.4B$9.2A7B4.B2ABA.3A18.4B$9.2AB
2A2BABA3.B6A2.A16.B2A2B$10.3BA.2AB.A3.A.B4.A18.2A$8.3B.B2ABAB2A4.6A$
8.2A4.B2A6.2AB2.A$9.A6.A.2A2.B2A.A3.A$6.3A5.A.A.2A3.8A$6.A7.2A7.3B$
25.2BA.2A$26.2A.2A!

However, something wrong happened during processing of the submitted RLE, leading to a corrupted pattern on Catagolue (gun_1650). Here is a quote from the log ( https://gitlab.com/hatsya/open-source/c ... 6946321794 ):

Code: Select all

x = 0, y = 0, rule = B3/S23
31bo$30bobo$30bobo$6b2o5b2o2b2ob2o7b2ob2o3bo$6bo2b2obo2bo2bob2o7bo5b2o
bo$7b2obob2ob2obo11b3ob2obo2bo$3b2o3bobo4bo2bob2o10b4obob2o7b2o$o2bo2b
obob2obobob2ob2o15bo10bo$3o2b6o4bo3bo17bo8bobo$3b2o6bo7bo12bo3bo5b2ob
3o$2bo2bo6bobo3bo11b2o10bob2o$3b2o8bo3bo13b2o10b2o$31bobo8b3o$30bo13bo
$9b2o18bo5bo5bo6b2o$2o6bo2bo6b2o16bo4bo3b2o2bo$bo7b2o7bo9bo2b2o2bo11b
2o$bobo12bobo10bo6bo5b2obo$2b2o12b2o7b2o6b3o9bob2o$20b2o2bobo7bo9b2ob
2o$21bo2bo$19bo2b3o6b3o$19b3o9bo10b2o$22bo15b6o4b2o$21b2o14b5o5b3o$36b
obo3bo2b2o2b2o$34b3o2bob3obob2o2bo$33bo4bobo2bobo2bob2o$8bo25b5obob2ob
2obo$7bobo8b2o20bobo2bo2bob2o$7bobo9b2o2bo12b3obobobo2b2ob2o$8bo11b4o
7b2o3bo2bo3bo$12b2o7b2o8bobo3b2o$12bobo6b2ob2o7bo$14bo8b3o7b2o$14b2o4$
21b2ob2o$17b2o3bob2o2b2o$17bo2bobo6bo$19b2ob7o$21bo$21bob4o$22b2o2bo2$
36bo$35bobo$23b2o9bo3b2o3b2o$23b2o9bo3b2o3b2o$20bo13bo3b2o$21bo13bobo$
19b3o14bo!
Checking periodicity with exponent 10...
Checking periodicity with exponent 12...
Checking periodicity with exponent 14...
True period: 1650
Stream period: 1650
#CSYNTH gun_1650 costs 2915 cells.
#C period 1650 fullperiod 1650 bbox 53 by 55

Crossposting a bug. The offending non-gun was submitted at some point between 2024-05-25 and 2024-06-05.

[...]
Initially I thought that red spike appeared because of my mistake, but upon further investigation, it turned out to be a bug in Catagolue verification, here is what caused this spike: gun_1650 [...]

[Vort]

The offending non-gun was submitted at some point between 2024-05-25 and 2024-06-05.

Turned out, this gun was uploaded by me, I forgot about it, sorry.

However, something wrong happened during processing of the submitted RLE, leading to a corrupted pattern on Catagolue

I noticed strange bounding box calculations by Catagolue several months ago.
Because I wasn't sure if it's a bug or not and because changing of calculation will invalidate area values for many guns, I did not talked about it.
Also this problem was "silent". Now, when explosive consequences were discovered, something should be done with it.

In gun_1650 case, Catagolue detects bounding box of 53x55 and then crops gun in this state:

Code: Select all

x = 52, y = 57, rule = B3/S23
31bo$30bobo$30bobo$6b2o5b2o2b2ob2o7b2ob2o2b2o$6bo2b2obo2bo2bob2o7bo5bo
2bo$7b2obob2ob2obo11b3o4bo2bo$3b2o3bobo2bobo2bob2o10bo2bobob2o7b2o$o2b
o2bo4bo3bob2o2bo11b2o2bo10bo$3o2b2obo3bobobo2bo16b2o7b2obo$3b2o2b5o6b
2o22b2o3bo$2bo2bo6b2o4bo23bo$3b2o8bo16b2o$29bo2bo9bo2bo$30b2o10bobo$9b
2o34bo2b2o$2o6bo2bo6b2o18bobo5bo2bo$bo7b2o7bo18b3o2bob2ob2o$bobo12bobo
17bob2o4bo$2b2o12b2o7b2o9b2o5bobob2o$20b2o2bobo17b2ob2o$21bo2bo$19bo2b
3o$19b3o8bo8b2o2bo$22bo5b2o7bo5bo3bobo$21b2o6b2o12bo2b2o$36bo6b3o4bo$
16b2o16b3ob4obobob2o2bo$16bobo14bo4bobo4bo2bob2o$8bo7bo17b5obob2ob2obo
$7bobo30bobo2bo2bob2o$7bobo26b3obobobo2b2ob2o$8bo22b2o3bo2bo3bo$12b2o
17bobo3b2o$12bobo18bo$14bo7b2o9b2o$14b2o6bo2bo$22bo2bo$22bo2$21b2o3bo$
17b2o3bob2o2b2o$17bo2bobo6bo$19b2ob7o$21bo$21bob4o$22b2o2bo2$33bobo$
33bo3bo$23b2o12bo5b2o$23b2o8bo4bo4b2o$37bo$33bo3bo$23bo9bobo$23b2o2$
22b2o!

This results in the loss of the bottom two cells and a subsequent explosion.

[confocaloid]

There are known cases (now gun_1650 included too), where Catagolue fails to correctly determine the bounding box of the gun. Several examples can be found by searching for keywords "bounding box glitch".
search.php?keywords=bounding+glitch

[...]
I noticed strange bounding box calculations by Catagolue several months ago.
Because I wasn't sure if it's a bug or not and because changing of calculation will invalidate area values for many guns, I did not talked about it.
Also this problem was "silent". Now, when explosive consequences were discovered, something should be done with it.
[...]

In this case, the correct bounding box is 57-by-53. In the following phase, there is a glider that will fail to escape away; since that glider does not escape, all cells that are alive at least once during the lifetime of the glider and its interaction with xp30_w33z8kqrqk8zzzw33 belong in the bounding box of the gun. The canonical phase (the one with an output glider about to leave the bounding box) appears 845 ticks later:

Code: Select all

#C [[ MAXGRIDSIZE 9 HARDRESET STOP 845 ]]
x = 54, y = 53, rule = LifeHistory
31.2B$7.2A6.A13.6B$8.A6.3A11.7B$8.A.A7.A9.9B$6.2A.A.A5.2A10.9B$6.A2.A
.A5.5B7.10B$8.A.A8.3B6.12B$3.2A2.2A7.7B4.9B.4B$3.A.A2.BAB5.7B2.4B2A3B
4.4B$5.2AB3A4.A12BA2BA2B5.4B$4.A2.AB2A2B.ABA12B2A2B7.4B$4.3A2B2A3BABA
15B9.4B$7.A.2A3.BA18B8.4B$4.2A.2AB2A3.10B.B5.2A9.4B$3.A.3A2B2A4.10B6.
A11.4B$3.A4.B.B8.8B6.3A9.4B$4.5AB7.6B.4B7.A10.4B$5.A2.A2B6.2A6.4B18.
4B$3.A3.A.A2B6.A7.4B10.2A6.3BA$3.5AB2A4.3A9.4B9.A8.ABA$8.3A4.A5.2A5.
4B.2B7.A7.2A$3.2A.ABA10.A2.A5.BA5B6.2A$3.2A.2A11.2A.A.AB.B3A6B.BAB2.
2A$21.A.3A.5A7B4A2.A$21.A3.3A3B2A7B2.A.2A3.2A$19.3A3.3A3B3A5B2A.A.A3.
B2A2B$18.A6.B2A3B2A4B.B2A.A.A4.4B$18.2A5.2B5A4B3.B.BA.2A4.4B$15.5B4.
4B3AB.B8.A6.4B$12.3B3A5.6BA2B8.A.A6.4B$3.2A6.3BA3BAB2.4B2.3B9.2A6.5B$
.3A.A4.3BA5BA5B3.5B15.2BA2B$A4.A3.4BA5BA4B7.2A14.2B3A2B$.3A.2A2.4BA5B
A3B8.A15.2B3A2B$3.2A.BAB3.2BA3BA3B5.A4.3A12.7B$5.B2AB3.3B3A2B6.A.A5.A
12.2A3B2A$4.3BA2B3.8B5.A.A18.2A3B2A$3.AB3.AB4.8B3.2A.A.2A15.7B$3.A.4A
5.8B.2BA2.A.A.A15.5B$4.A10.11BABA.A.A15.2BA2B$6.A9.4B.4BAB.B2.A17.ABA
B$5.2A8.3B4.3B2AB3A18.2B2A$10.B3.2B7.2B.A23.B2AB$9.2A7B4.B2ABA.3A18.B
3A$9.2AB2A2BABA3.B6A2.A16.BABAB$10.3BA.2AB.A3.A.B4.A18.2A$8.3B.B2ABAB
2A4.6A$8.2A4.B2A6.2AB2.A$9.A6.A.2A2.B2A.A3.A$6.3A5.A.A.2A3.8A$6.A7.2A
7.3B$25.2BA.2A$26.2A.2A!

[Vort]

... since that glider does not escape, all cells that are alive at least once during the lifetime of the glider and its interaction with xp30_w33z8kqrqk8zzzw33 belong in the bounding box of the gun. ...

Thanks for confirming that this is indeed a bug.
I made bug report describing this problem: Issue #30.

[Chris857]

I mentioned this on Discord a few days ago but will repeat it here:

I found a few patterns where there's an intermediate step that's cheaper, but the final pattern shows a more expensive step for some reason. This happened for a couple spaceships and oscillators even where I submitted something recently that should have lowered the cost.

• xq4_y258880638gszwu1w32gkoz34j0ozx11 claims to cost 68G and shows the intermediate xp2_o8y62c34z012462461tazw8ak4y0113 as costing 12G over the still life, but that particular page shows it costing only 8G over the still life to add the clocks

• xq4_y0gmdxsg8zsg4knfzwg01f6zw321 claims to cost 51G and shows the intermediate xp2_06a8o0o4a952zy1hhowca23gg8z653032y5211 as costing 6G to add the clock, but that particular page shows it costing only 4G

• 6 David Hilbert variants have syntheses at https://catagolue.hatsya.com/census/b3s ... costs/xp23, three costing 91G and three 96G, but they all start with xs32_ydo8b9czyg356zo8gz0d5k46zw11 which costs 12G in one step, but the expensive synths show it as 17G in five steps, despite being the exact same pair of still lifes