Mystery (Game)

[BokaBB]

But he has no known connection with the flowers,that complicates the case. The only suspect known of liking them is Jane.

Yes, but no suspect makes everything fit, as Jane has no motive for stealing the church icon, so something must be a red herring.

There is a suspect that matches them all, you just have to find it out. It is easier than you think!
Please say the reason for each suspect why you don't think it is the thief.
Have a good day!

BokaBB

[BokaBB]

A hint:One or both of the Peter-Jane duo at least influenced the theft,if they didn't have done it.
Have a good day!

BokaBB

[Schiaparelliorbust]

I rule out Nick because he doesn't have a motive and even though he was a criminal in the past, he wants to change. I feel that Jane could have somehow left the flowers and/or the clock without actually committing the crime. My best guess is Sam.

[BokaBB]

I rule out Nick because he doesn't have a motive and even though he was a criminal in the past, he wants to change. I feel that Jane could have somehow left the flowers and/or the clock without actually committing the crime. My best guess is Sam.

You are on a right path,but still not even close to the truth. Please think a bit more.
Have a good day!

BokaBB

[Schiaparelliorbust]

I rule out Nick because he doesn't have a motive and even though he was a criminal in the past, he wants to change. I feel that Jane could have somehow left the flowers and/or the clock without actually committing the crime. My best guess is Sam.

You are on a right path,but still not even close to the truth. Please think a bit more.
Have a good day!

BokaBB

In movies I often see innocent people being near the scene of the crime right before or after the crime has been committed. Did something like that happen? It could explain the flowers and/or the clock.

[MathAndCode]

What if Peter stole the icon, put it in the trunk of his car, rearranged the items already them in order to make room, and accidentally dropped Jane's clock and flowers without noticing because he was in a hurry to get away?

[BokaBB]

What if Peter stole the icon, put it in the trunk of his car, rearranged the items already them in order to make room, and accidentally dropped Jane's clock and flowers without noticing because he was in a hurry to get away?

Bingo! Altrough he was purchasing the clock and the flower for her. When he backed to get them,police already removed them.
According to our agreement I will make the new Mystery myself if MathAndCode wins.
Have a good day!

BokaBB

[MathAndCode]

Bingo! Altrough he was purchasing the clock and the flower for her. When he backed to get them,police already removed them.

I think that that rules out the possibility of Jane helping Peter because she likely would have kept better track of her own things and because if she were Peter's accomplice, then she could have made room in the trunk while Peter was inside the church so that Peter wouldn't have had to rearrange it in a hurry once he returned to the car. Since there is no indication that John or Nick knew Peter, I conclude that they were not involved. There is a theoretical possibility that Peter stole the icon in order to trade it to Sam for the clock, but since Peter would not have needed Sam's tools and Sam likely would not have given Peter the clock until after Peter had the icon, I shall conclude that Peter acted alone.

[BokaBB]

I ask Schaparelio if he can create a Mystery. If not, I will.
Have a good day!

BokaBB

[Schiaparelliorbust]

I ask Schaparelio if he can create a Mystery. If not, I will.
Have a good day!

BokaBB

I will try to make one, I will edit this post. I will start working on it now.
Edit:
A blind man was found unconscious from a gunshot. He was taken to the hospital and survived. His phone was stolen from him. The man said that the perpetrator was wearing gloves and a cap, so no DNA was found.
Suspects:
Tania: Neighbour of the blind man. Known to have good relations with him, but she owes the man some money after he helped her buy her house.
Tyrone: Blind man's employee. Has been asking for a raise for a while but because he is performing poorly, the blind man hasn't given him one.
Max: Owes money to his landlord and lives in a poor neighbourhood near where the blind man was found lying, though is known to be nice to others.
Gabriela: Owns a rival business to the blind man. Is the landlord of Max. Needs money for surgery.
Seth: Blind man's old business partner, but was found to be stealing cash from the register for himself.

[BokaBB]

I ask Schaparelio if he can create a Mystery. If not, I will.
Have a good day!

BokaBB

I will try to make one, I will edit this post. I will start working on it now.
Edit:
A blind man was found unconscious from a gunshot. He was taken to the hospital and survived. His phone was stolen from him. The man said that the perpetrator was wearing gloves and a cap, so no DNA was found.
Suspects:
Tania: Neighbour of the blind man. Known to have good relations with him, but she owes the man some money after he helped her buy her house.
Tyrone: Blind man's employee. Has been asking for a raise for a while but because he is performing poorly, the blind man hasn't given him one.
Max: Owes money to his landlord and lives in a poor neighbourhood near where the blind man was found lying, though is known to be nice to others.
Gabriela: Owns a rival business to the blind man. Is the landlord of Max. Needs money for surgery.
Seth: Blind man's old business partner, but was found to be stealing cash from the register for himself.

I can automatically erase Tania. I think Max and possibly also Gabriela too. The only people I think have the chance to do that are Tyrone or Seth. I will guess Tyrone is since he has motive and no things that dismiss him.
Seth is also possible,but he has less motive.
Gabriela could be the attacker,but I want to collect more evidence first. Has blind man lost any money?
Please play my new games!
Have a good day!

BokaBB

[Schiaparelliorbust]

I can automatically erase Tania. I think Max and possibly also Gabriela too. The only people I think have the chance to do that are Tyrone or Seth. I will guess Tyrone is since he has motive and no things that dismiss him.
Seth is also possible,but he has less motive.
Gabriela could be the attacker,but I want to collect more evidence first. Has blind man lost any money?
Please play my new games!
Have a good day!

BokaBB

Money was transferred from his bank account to another anonymous user through his phone.

[BokaBB]

I can automatically erase Tania. I think Max and possibly also Gabriela too. The only people I think have the chance to do that are Tyrone or Seth. I will guess Tyrone is since he has motive and no things that dismiss him.
Seth is also possible,but he has less motive.
Gabriela could be the attacker,but I want to collect more evidence first. Has blind man lost any money?
Please play my new games!
Have a good day!

BokaBB

Money was transferred from his bank account to another anonymous user through his phone.

I think Gabriela has high chances of being the attacker,but I want more hints and evidence since I mostly don't yet have any ideas that are sure.
Have a good day!

BokaBB

[Schiaparelliorbust]

I think Gabriela has high chances of being the attacker,but I want more hints and evidence since I mostly don't yet have any ideas that are sure.
Have a good day!

BokaBB

Think of the different connections between people.
Edit:
Hint: The blind man says he didn't hear anyone approach him.

[MathAndCode]

A blind man was found unconscious from a gunshot. He was taken to the hospital and survived. His phone was stolen from him. The man said that the perpetrator was wearing gloves and a cap, so no DNA was found.

How would each suspect have access to a gun?

[the lifestroyer]

i think it was suicide and the blind man wanted to blame other people for the murder and in the meanwhile do something else while police are busy.its because the Blind man said the perpetrayor was having a hat and gloves
Hundreth post woooooooooooooooooooooooot

[MathAndCode]

the Blind man said the perpetrayor was having a hat and gloves

There's a problem with that: The blind man wouldn't have been able to dispose of the gun while unconscious, and no gun was found at the scene. Maybe the blind man felt the perpetrator's gloves as the perpetrator stole the man's phone before falling completely unconscious? (I'm not sure about the hat, though.)

[Schiaparelliorbust]

the Blind man said the perpetrayor was having a hat and gloves

There's a problem with that: The blind man wouldn't have been able to dispose of the gun while unconscious, and no gun was found at the scene. Maybe the blind man felt the perpetrator's gloves as the perpetrator stole the man's phone before falling completely unconscious? (I'm not sure about the hat, though.)

Sorry, ignore that completely. I miswrote the premise. Change that to "The police reached the conclusion that the person that stole the phone was wearing gloves and a mask.". Sorry, this is my first mystery. If you need any more hints, tell me.

[BokaBB]

i think it was suicide and the blind man wanted to blame other people for the murder and in the meanwhile do something else while police are busy.its because the Blind man said the perpetrayor was having a hat and gloves
Hundreth post woooooooooooooooooooooooot

Calm down,please,I never celebrated any my post.
Please buy some Durian!
Have a good day!

BokaBB

[BokaBB]

According to your hint I think one from Max - Gabriela duo could be the suspect. Max is extremely unlikely and I think it could be Gabriela.
How was Seth stealing cash?
Have a good day!

BokaBB

[Schiaparelliorbust]

According to your hint I think one from Max - Gabriela duo could be the suspect. Max is extremely unlikely and I think it could be Gabriela.
How was Seth stealing cash?
Have a good day!

BokaBB

Seth was stealing cash from the register for some time, so he technically owes some money to the business, but the blind man decided to drop all charges. He thinks that cutting his income from the business is enough punishment.

[BokaBB]

Please say. I don't know.
Have a good day!

BokaBB

[Schiaparelliorbust]

Please say. I don't know.
Have a good day!

BokaBB

Hint: There were a few bullets found a bit far away from the blind man.

[MathAndCode]

Hint: There were a few bullets found a bit far away from the blind man.

Where were the bullets found? Did Max fire at the blind man from his house or yard?

[Schiaparelliorbust]

Where were the bullets found? Did Max fire at the blind man from his house or yard?

We never said that Max had attacked him, first of all. Second of all, they were all found to his left.